William Tell's Rough Draft
by roba

Comment:
Great idea and well done. Would have loved to see a little more "punch" in the picture. Maybe the a slight change of the angle of the light would have done it?

When the Cat's Away...
by missykim

Comment:
I think there is a lot of creativity and work behind this picture. But this is not a creativity contest. It is all about the picture.

The composition is not bad, but the lighting is extremely flat. From the shadows in the picture, I suspect the use of flash. If this had been done with a softer flash, a fill light and a reflector or two, the quality of the picture would have been lifted dramatically.

Also, the background in this picture could have been made a bit more interesting. It is a shame to put so much work in a part of the picture and not go the whole distance.