Shades of Green
by roba

Comment:
The color bleed in the white of the eye detracts from a well captured portrait of a beautifull model. Still a very nice picture.

Oxtroit
by heida

Comment:
I find the bright spot to be very distracting to an otherwise well executed and processed picture. Would have rated it higher with out the glare.

S H Y
by hihosilver

Comment:
For me this is the best of this challenge, what a jem of a capture. - 10

Colourful Tubes
by Omni

Comment:
Of the other tube images is this challlenge I like this one the best because there is no hot spot from the light source that wipes out the image in the field shown.

Ever so quiet Gardenia
by Xilebo

Comment:
This is a beautiful image with sharp focus but soft overall grain. One of my favorites so far

World War II - Officer's Respite
by yakatme

Comment:
Toning would have been better is light sepia for me.

Kate by Candlelight
by splidge

Comment:
Low level lighting produced a mild overall grain to this image that is complimentary to the total quality of this capture, Very Nice

Like a moth to a flame...
by Mal37

Comment:
Nice composition but the soft main image is off for me. Nice background grain.

Focus on the Target!
by LVicari

Comment:
This image has great potential, the reflected target in the glasses is well executed and the general composition is good, however, the lack of texture in the "arrow" shaft and lack of feathers really kill its potential. Never saw a braided bow string. A retake with a real arrow and different string will make this an outstanding shot IMHO.

The Spectators at ISO 3200
by jaysonmc

Comment:
Not a bad idea with the main subject forward and in the right third but she is out of sharp focus, different cropping limiting the harsh yellow background would have been better, the onlookers being out of focus would be good if the other comments were corrected.