Old Technology Meets New
by ganders

Comment:
I think I see a slight reflection in the lens of a person? I understand the concept of the photo, but think that it could have been executed a bit better... perhaps just a more "clear" reflection on the lense could help dramatically. Just a minor pet peeve as well, is the Sigma lens cap. It's quite soft on the focus and makes it difficult to read the text. Overall, meets the challenge. Creative shot, but could have been executed a bit better... - 5 - JB

Reflection Of Time
by togtog

Comment:
I don't understand how this meets the challenge - unless the whole clock is a reflection, which it doesn't seem to be? Technically, it seems to be soft on focus, which I think detracts from the photo. The large shadow at the to p1/3 to 1/2 is distracting as well.... I have to mark this down, as I don't see that it fits the challenge... :( - 3 - JB

Ghost Ship
by inspzil

Comment:
This is a fantastic shot! The fog/haze really sets a mood for the shot. You know it will be ok soon though, because the sun will burn it all off :) Youv'e definitely met the challenge with this shot, and subject matter is very appealing to me. - 8 - JB

Place de Catalogne, Paris, Ricardo Boffil, 1985
by lionelm

Comment:
Although it isn't the most "original" photo of the week - the content is among the best in my opinion. The texture/contour of the glass is great. Nice shot! - 9 - JB

splash
by willem

Comment:
This is a neat shot! It's a conventional splash... but the reflection is good! Very nice coloring. Object is well composed. - 8 - JB

Quiet Reflection - No Mirror
by Simms

Comment:
This is a neat shot... I'm not sure how well it meets the "literal" translation of reflection, but quite imaginative... Why does it need to meet the literal translation though? Meet the challenge? In a unique way, yes. Composition - A+ Creativity - A+++ :) Overall - 8 - JB

Ready to Race a Semi
by alanfreed

Comment:
Great vantage point for this shot! I'm drawn to the "reflective" portion of the wheel immediately. - JB

Four Eyes
by vtruan

Comment:
I would love to give this a higher score... I really like the idea! It just seems... a bit harsh? Definitely meets the challenege... definitely has appeal... just a bit off technically. - 7 - JB

Corner? My whole world...
by myqyl

Comment:
Very nice photograph. Technically, could be improved... the little girl seems to have moved on you a bit :) The color seems to be a bit flat. The crop seems to be a hair tight on the right hand side? As far as content, a definite 10... It's pleasing to see that instead of trying to find a smart, clever shot for this challenege, somebody just used the basics of what their life REALLY is... Congrats! - JB

Where The Buffalo Roam (Wyoming)
by Sonifo

Comment:
Wow... That's awesome that you were able to capture this. The picture, in it's entirety works very well. I like the first buffalo being as close as it is - you can imagine the size of the animal... But the rest of the picture makes you realize just how "small" it really is :) Very nice shot... 8 - JB