Naturally Framed Entry
by MrAnalogy

Comment:
Brilliant title!

Old Methodist Burying Ground
by Bear_Music

Comment:
I've been away Robert, so I'm seeing this challenge for the first time right now. This is great; it does everything you & Ed Clarke suggested in a forum would be required to do well. Full tonal range, with retained detail at every point on that range, etc, etc. Plus it's a damn fine photograph even without its AA tribute qualities. Congratulations on this & on your exceptional contribution to the DPC community.

Go Wild at the Dallas Zoo! Visit "The Wilds of Africa" Today!
by L1

Comment:
Terrific photograph! Great composition and well executed. Title's no good for a billboard; too long. "Go Wild. Dallas Zoo." would do the trick nicely. But that's beside the point here; this is a very good billboard image. 9

Subaru, Hot to Handle
by JohannesFrank

Comment:
This is a great shot, well composed & cropped to capture the "Don't tread on me!" character of this awesome little machine. Of course, adding the text would probably ruin the look of your image, but it would still be a terrific billboard with no text at all, and the word "SUBARU" made just a little more prominent. But this challenge is just about the image, and yours is excellent. 9

You weren't planning on walking up there in sneakers, were you? - Mountain Guides Next Exit
by jayrod

Comment:
Good photograph, unworkable title (for a billboard slogan). But the image is really striking. 7

Last year, one out of ten only considered Flu Vaccination a good idea.
by jjbeguin

Comment:
Terrific photograph. The title is the right sentiment but too long for a billboard. "Who's had their flu shot?" or something like it, would work better. Also a bit hard to figure out where the words would go on the billboard. However, I have not marked this excellent entry down for that, because this is about the image, and yours is very good. 8

Time Passes Slowly for a Widower
by EricSorenW

Comment:
This is very effective & moving; a quiet despair, well captured and presented in this spare composition. 7

"Bartleby The Scrivner"
by pawdrix

Comment:
I think Melville might have loved this photograph (although he may have lamented the spelling of "scrivener"). The cropped anonymity, the blank wall, and the dead flowers he "preferred not to give water" are most apposite. 7

Daydreaming Nightmares
by jmritz

Comment:
This is powerful because it's disturbing. Many interpretations are possible, none of which seem comfortable. 7.

Tuned In
by librodo

Comment:
Very nice portrait that effortlessly satisfies the challenge subject as well. 7