Still
by rscorp

Comment:
Returning for comment. DOF is excellent and makes this shot. Composition is very strong, and this image has tons of depth. Black and white was a good choice. Overall, a very good image that should do very well. Good luck in the challenge!

Bullseye
by jodiecoston

Comment:
Returning for comment. Super strong lines and bold colors really make this pop off the screen. The liquid sloshing to the right really gives this shot lots of visual interest. I do see a teensy bit of a break in the black circle within the wine glass reflection which makes me wonder about cloning, but it didn't affect the score because I had to study the image to find it and I'm not positive it's a PP mistake. Very nice job!

The Bellevue - call for reservations
by Refwhett

Comment:
Excellent toning. Too bad the sky is blown out, though.

Follow the Leader
by DrAchoo

Comment:
Excellent job here - colors really pop.

Place of Prayer
by kiwiness

Comment:
Excellent job here. Very strong lines in the composition, and lighting is terrific.

Speedboat Racer
by briphoto

Comment:
Nice job with the panning.

The Entertainer
by geewhy

Comment:
Super stong image here. Very nice.

The Tallest One
by AzCKelly

Comment:
Super duper nice job here. Composition is strong, exposure is spot-on, colors are vibrant, perspective works well. Overall, this is a very strong image that should do well. Good luck!

Four Years Later
by Konador

Comment:
Ahhh, a new favorite image for me! Having seen the "4 years ago" version, I'm delighted and amazed to see how closely you've matched the original vision. Super, fantastic, wonderfully well done. Composition is very strong, lighting is perfect, and that is the most amazing eye detail I've seen since the last one you did. Good luck, Benbo!

I saw red
by Elvis_L

Comment:
Good use of DOF. With regard to composition - looks a bit tight on the right side. Lighting looks a bit harsh - sometimes it's easier to capture projects like this in early morning or late afternoon.