Infrared Rocks!
by marbo

Comment:
Hmm, saw a similar shot in free study, same person? Anyway, good shot, hope the lack of scissors or paper hurts your score.

Prowling
by snackwells

Comment:
A very nice shot of a tiger, I would have rated this high in "wildlife" or something similar but what has this shot got to do with the theme of rock paper scissors. I know according to the challenge specifications you only need to have one of those items in the shot but here the rock is in such a minor role that IMHO this shot is totally off topic. Please PM with me if you dissagree but I felt that you were entitled to an explanation as to why I am only giving this a 4. I would probably have given this 7-8 if this had been on topic.

Achieving balance
by nico_blue

Comment:
Not a bad idea but the backround is way to busy for this, as it is now the backround draws my attention more than the scissors and that´s bad but the shot is still better than most in the challenge so I gave it a 6.

... and then she goes down ...
by eirasi

Comment:
I am a sucker for these kind of sunset shots and I like this but IMHO you could have composed it better (at least to my special taste anyway) by moving to the left and placing the tree in the right side of the frame and the sun exactly where it is. I Still a very good shot so don´t get me wrong and hope I didn´t offend you. (8)

After the storm
by nico_blue

Comment:
Don´t take this as I percieve the shot to be illegaly edited, I don´t but I just don´t like the look in this image. Way too dramatic and this is overkill, too much dodge/burn for my taste (or whatever you used to get this) but this is just my personal taste, if you like this that should be all that matters. I gave it a 5 though because I like the composition and thought behind the shot but the final version isn´t to my taste. Good luck in the challenge.

Doom Watch
by Imagineer

Comment:
A W E S O M E shot, my only 10 in the challenge and just WOW. Added it to my favorites and while I don´t want to jinx you, hope to see you on the front page in a week. Love everything about it, great job especially on the lighting and capturing that killer expression.

Mount Olympus
by dsidwell

Comment:
Excellent shot in regards to colour, contrast and sharpness and I love that sky so good job on the post processing but the rocks in the foreground are taking up way too much space for my taste so I "only" gave it a 7. Good job nevertheless.

Helping Hands
by graphicfunk

Comment:
Clever, but not very aesthetically pleasing, no interesting lighting or nothing really dramatic or interesting thing going on so no offense intended, I just gave it a 6 but would have just given a 3-4 if the double hand effect hadn´t been there.

Sitting on supper
by arpita

Comment:
Love the DOF in this shot, sharpness, colour and contrast and just about everything. Only bad thing I can really say is that I don´t really find this shot interesting but technically it´s perfectly done, gave it a 9.

Lake Infrared
by marbo

Comment:
Very cool! Normally I don´t like infrared shots but this one is pretty good, I gave it an 8. Good luck in the challenge.