Through Life
by -Bec-

Comment:
I like the idea itself but I think you could have executed it better, what bothers me most is the lighting used here, kindof hard and strong on the dress and then next to none on the lady in the backround. Looks so off even that I am strongly suspecting that the lady is in fact just a picture you printed out or cut out of a magazine and put up on a wall in the backround, again, because of the difference in lighting. Like I said, like the idea, just needs better execution.

One Step at a Time
by dsa157

Comment:
Ummm, not really the expert here but seems to me he is on his way down, not up, ergo no progress really but what the heck, that is just nitpicking and I didn´t let that affect the score at all, I am not THAT petty, hehe :P

Shot is nice, nothing that is blowing me away. Decently exposed and composed though, gave it a 6.

"Regression"--This image was disqualified from the Progress challenge
by charliebaker

Comment:
You fishing for a whole bunch of low ratings? Well I have a strong feeling this is an attempt at getting the lowest score all time here at dpc so I am gonna attempt to foil your plan and "troll" you, did the exact opposite, 10 from me :P

Natural Selection
by Nald

Comment:
Lol! Somehow I just dig the "expression" on the dragonfish, nice work, also technically speaking, crystal clear and sharp, excellent image quality.

The Price We Pay
by owen

Comment:
Nice shot, like how the ripples in the water lead the eye towards the factory. 7 from me.

Practice, Practice, Practice
by judojoe

Comment:
I´d watch out, that little girl looks mean and I wouldn´t wanna run into her in a dark alley, she´d probably kick my ass :P

Nice shot, great tones in it and love the expressions on the models :)

Transportation Symphony in D minor
by rjkstesch

Comment:
Jeez, what a maze! Progress my ass, DNMC!!! Just kidding :) Like this shot, well composed and great b/w tones too. 7 from me.

From Wind To Electricity: The Power Of Progress?
by obsidian

Comment:
Sorry but not at all fond of the strong halo around the subject, definately a turnoff for me personally, would have given a 5 but that knocked you down to a 4.

HOLD ON
by bonnett

Comment:
Love the dof and bokeh, just wish the whole image was a bit brighter as the backround is kindof too dark and blends in with the foreground because of that. 6 from me.

One Stick at a time
by hahn23

Comment:
This shot is pretty cool, awesome moment you captured here. Franky, I think this is likely to ribbon in this challenge, however, I "only" gave it a 7. There is something with the backround that throws me a bit off this image, somehow the difference in lighting and the fact that it´s so busy despite being out of focus draws too much of my attention from the bird and the nest. Like I said, still gave this a 7 and wouldn´t be surprised to see this ribbon or at least make top 10, this should do well here.