Simply Amazing
by bruski

Comment:
I would say something but I lost my jaw :P

The last leaf
by akshayvh

Comment:
Darn could be a powerfull picture, but these "rollers what ever they are called" destroy the efect.

Jack Frost's Artistry
by C-Fox

Comment:
Going for the amazing part ... well i am not on my knees yet. Don't like the snow in the background. The title is good. The idea is not bad either.

Everyday's a Bad Feather Day. -- Goose with a Feather Birth Defect.
by fulgent

Comment:
The title doesn't work at all. The pic itself is funny and meets the chalange.
Don't like the "thing" in the right hend corner ( but my guess is - that it was unavoidable )You could take this shot now or never. If it wasn't like this then ... :)

Heavenly Glow
by Truegsht

Comment:
Hope you're not beeing marked down for the grain. Not all of us have D20 :)
I like the shot but neither it is funny nor amazing. Well a nice , well made shot.

Edge of the World
by JCDean

Comment:
What I like:
-Creative
-DOF

Well I understand the idea. You where aming for the amazing part and no for the funny one.
After a short time it does look like a cliff or the edge of the world. Very creative but lacks something pompous. On the other heand i'am not sure if you could make it more pompous. So i give a 7 for the creativity. The shot itself doesn't have the impact matching the title.

ShroomHenge
by L1

Comment:
What I like
-love the greens
-love the way you set the mashrooms
-I like pictures that show creativity
-The title fits on a dime

I would chan ge nothing in this pic. Very very creative 10 from me!

Birds on the Shoreline
by andywightman

Comment:
What I like:
-damn what an interesting picture
-damn what nice composition
-damn what colours
-damn what perspective
What I dislike:
-Well I dislike me for not beeing able to shoot a pic like that :)

I give it a 10. It is striking in the form and also in the situation it conveys.

alien
by slonko

Comment:
What I like:
-The title
-recently I've seen alien vs predator and well This shot fits :)
-The colours are cold but i feel warm
-The water gives a nice effecr
What I dislike:
-Well don't really know. Maybe i would give a frame, even if it was 1 pixel thick :P

I give you a 9.
Good picture, creative or just lucky, fits the chal;ange. No more to say.

Undressed
by smr78

Comment:
What I like:
-everything that is,

The composition
The lighting
The figure
The gradient ( I love gradients )
The tone of the sky
What I dislike:
-The border is too white :) Maybe too thick - maybe the old conventional black would do better :)
-I am not sure where the amazement is gone, or the laugh :) Bizzare it is not !

So the shot itself is 8 point worth but since the topic is bizzare nature I give it a 6.