Fill my cup
by shaydn

Comment:
I think some back lighting on this photo would of worked better. I seems to lack the lighting required to stop the motion and give the view are crisp shot to look at. Not a bad photo but I feel it could of been better. I wish you the best in the challenge.

Brains
by gclark

Comment:
Lacks proper focus and lighting and noisy. Wish you the best in the challenge.

The Gate
by roba

Comment:
Very busy and (to me) unidentifiable.

breakwater
by idp

Comment:
Nice reflections, composition, and tone. Looks like a good sky that day to take a picture of this location.

(((((PURE)))))
by TacTZilla

Comment:
Very good job with lighting to make the ripples in the water stand out.

Spillway at sunset
by CEJ

Comment:
I like the texture and color.

At Home
by Fromac

Comment:
Nice ripples in the water. I like how its light on the left and dark on the right, the water that is. But I do feel the duck is to dark and especially in the neck and face.

dew drops
by roz

Comment:
Nice broken and I like the lighting on the wings. Kinda wish the dew drops would of stopped at the bottom of the wing and continued on to body. It really gets busy at that point. Minor distraction but still a good shot.

Polar Ball
by TommyMoe21

Comment:
Nice colors (blue water/red ball), however the subject is bland. I was looking for more creative water shots. Don't get me wrong your picture is good technically but lacks creativity. Good picture!

boat and duck
by pointandshoot

Comment:
Had the potential to be a good shot. But I don't understand all the sun flares in your picture. Did you have a UV filter on your camera? It don't look like your shooting directly into the sun. I find them very distracting and the shadow of the brush/grass on the top-left. I would of loved to see this image with smooth water allowing us to see the boat disappear under the water with contrast on the boat above the water.
Wish you well in the challenge. Nice B&W conversion.