Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Inconsistent shadows are a distraction. Not sure this is a good subject for HDR.
Post actions
the top of the bottle appears to be oof, and the background is much too close for my taste. interesting idea though, i would have never thought of it
Post actions
not obviously HDR , bet as ever it is , pretty nice picture too I rather like the apparent simplicity.
Post actions
You did a great volume and focus at this photo, but lacks a little interest.
Post actions
Does not have an obvious HDR appearance, though I am certain you did use such techniques. More importantly, though a good product shot, it just does not have anything about it that engages my interest. Seems like the bubbles should, but they don't. Contrast perhaps?
Post actions
The bottle is oof and i don't know if you did that, but looks like the bottle was moved between the captures. The shadows are really distracting too, but i like the B&W and textures. This doesn't look much HDR for me too. Sorry if i was rude, good luck.
Post actions
Post actions
Am I missing something here?
Post actions
I shall be rating this challenge by the following criteria:
Post actions
Looks more like Low Dymanic Range to me sorry.
Post actions
Did you really need HDR for this image?
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
