Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Really nice use of selective desat, I like this, looks like it probably took a long time to do.
Post actions
To where?? Excellent datail, interesting commentary piece. 8
Post actions
Post actions
Love the pp on this shot. It's very appealing. 7
Post actions
I'm hoping to leave comments on as many photo's in this challenge as possible... out of (currently) 1113 images, I gave 93 of them an 8. Your image was one of those 93, placing you well within the top 10% for this challenge.
Post actions
Strangely attractive processing.
Post actions
Nice over the top treatment of this.
Post actions
I love this PP job - its amazing - 10
Post actions
interesting post processing... six from me despite the noise ;D
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
The HDR like editing is applied too strongly in this instance, IMO.
Post actions
like the post processing in this one
Post actions
I like the look of the train but not too fond of the sky, I assume this is HDR or fake HDR? Sorry but I am not a fan of HDR.
Post actions
love the angle and the post processing
Post actions
Very nice image. It's good to see a few "great" images. This is a perfect reflection of your abilities as a photographer. HDR?
Post actions
Interesting use of desat.
Post actions
Gritty and urban. Nice work
Post actions
Cool colors to draw out the art work.
Post actions
The HDR works really well for this.
Post actions
Nice colors and use of grain
Post actions
The shadows on the trains are very interesting.
Post actions
Post actions
Intense post-processing makes this shot bold. Nice use of your digital tools to produce this image.
Post actions
Post actions
Bit to much processing for me but still a good pic.
Post actions
Very 'ghetto'. I like it.
Post actions
The selective desat on this is interesting. Not sure the composition is really doing it for me though.
Post actions
Interesting composition. You have a creative eye.
Post actions
i really like the shadows of the trees on the side of the train.
Post actions
nice pp work to make this stand out
Post actions
The grain in the sky adds to the graffiti subject. Nice blend and well processed.
Post actions
This is too heavily HDR processed for my liking. Interesting shot and angle though.
Post actions
I really like the treatment on this well done 8
Post actions
intriguing but dont know why
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
I really like this and I hope you're not taking a beating for it. A lot of voters just don't seem to like this kind of processing. I think the graininess really adds a nice effect. 8
Post actions
I dont like the wires but they kind of work here. Weird editing technique but that works to. hahaha. I guess I like it! hahah.
Post actions
really like the colors and tones...even the graininess of the shot
Post actions
I love this. I like graffiti art and you caught interesting art in an unusual setting. Grain works well. Cool.
Post actions
The train looks amazing, great post processing
Post actions
Post actions
I really like the colors and contrast. Good composition with the angled lines. My only nitpick is the sky seems grainy.
Post actions
Hmmm... Very intriguing. Obviously a lot of PP in this one. I'm not a big fan of these really unnatural looking HDRs, but the extra PP on this makes it obvious that you were going for a very stylized look. I like it a lot.
Post actions
processing is absolutely not my cup of tea; good POV; border is better than in your original image
Post actions
nice gritty photo, colours and grain work very well
Post actions
The processing really adds some emphasis to this, imo. So many stories to tell, and only a handful are seen.
Post actions
Interesting editing - especially the sky. A warm and cold image all at the same time. Nice juxtaposition.
Post actions
Post actions
I like how the image grain adds to the grittiness of the image.
Post actions
Tone-mapping always seems to have a hard time with thin lines like wires. I don't know why. You did a good job of containing it, but it still looks a little weird here and there. I love how sharp this is, and, unusually for me, I like the selective desat.
Post actions
Later I would be interested on how you got these effects, in other words yes I like it!!
Post actions
i don't really like the desaturation here, i like the angle and composition, but the flat sky takes away from the shot.
Post actions
Beautiful train wagon. Great post processing, although the sky looks somewhat artificially.
Post actions
Great post processing, bringing out the textures. I really like the grainy look.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
