Author Thread
Post actions
This actually had a lot of potential, but was poorly realized.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
I like the repetitive pattern of the boats.
Post actions
The reflections are ok, but I spend most of my time looking at the weeds towards the bottom. Perhaps if they were cropped out?!?1
Post actions
not a lot to hold my interest
Post actions
Not sharp enough to score well, I fear... but I like the abstractness of it.
Post actions
This seems quite out of focus to me, but I think the composition has potential.
Post actions
I like that the boats are in the upper corner of the shot.
Post actions
Needs to be a little sharper.
Post actions
maybe a polarizer would help
Post actions
Nice repetition with the boats, but seems flat...
Post actions
Nice POV creating good perspective.
Post actions
Post actions
good refelctions, and nice lines with created by the boats
Post actions
I really like the top of this photo (although the boats could have been focused sharper). The bottom half with the weeds is distracting. It would have been better composed without the weeds and with more boats.
Post actions
sorry , this does not appeal to me
Post actions
well its supposed to be reflections and there are really some but... bit uninteresting okay bit much (sorry for that) :D
Post actions
reflections are generally easier when the water isn't dirty (jokes)
Post actions
Good composition. Pity about the scattering of water plants in the foreground.
Post actions
Nice reflection of the light and the blue boats.
Post actions
Good idea. It needs a bit more color and detail to really stand out.
Post actions
I like the line of boats, would like to see more of them. Photo looks a bit dark and dull.
Post actions
I'm not really sure what the focus here is supposed to be... I guess the reflection of the boats (I assume those are boats) on the water? Its not very clear; I think a different angle would have been a better choice.
Post actions
I like the blue of the boats. Would have liked more of them and less of the water.
Post actions
Good idea but it needs something more.
Post actions
The composition is good. The photo lack an overall punch, or interest.
Post actions
personally (and I don't count) I would have cropped out the weeds in the front...it took me a minute to realize you were talking about the reflection of the boats...I was looking in/near the weeds...they do not add but distract
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Lacks sharpness, the colors are rather bland as well is the composition.
Post actions
Lacking in subject. Title says reflections and all I see is glare. A circular polarizer would have helped here to reduce glare. Needs some PP work.
Post actions
Post actions
I like the composition and the strong diagonal lines created by the boats.
Post actions
Post actions
This has a unique painterly feel to it. I like the blue tones.
Post actions
it's a little too soft and the light makes the image look flat
Post actions
Good composition, but out of focus foreground doesn't work very well, I think.
Post actions
I like the repetitive patterns
Post actions
I like the composition but to me it needs more focus and coloring work.
Post actions
might have been more interesting to focus on the plants rather than on the boats
Post actions
The foreground looks out of focus, a wider apeture would have helped this, (unless this was your intention?) The boats make for an almost leading lines but we are to perpendicular to the natural line the rear of the boats make. The reflections the boats make in the water is very nice. Best of luck.
Post actions
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
