Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Too bad they aren't interacting. The toning is interesting, yet something still seems off. I guess it's that neither of them are connecting with either the viewer or each other. They might as well be 10 feet apart.
Post actions
Very nice combination of the generations.
Post actions
Interesting commentary-style portraiture.
Post actions
Interesting juxtopositon here, I think it would look cool in color as well.
Post actions
Post actions
Nice generational portrait.
Post actions
good study in contrasts, perhaps your sepia is a bit heavy handed
Post actions
oh the toning :(... just three from me because of it
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Left portrait is excellent, right portrait is lacking
Post actions
Nice contrasts, both conceptual and physical.
Post actions
I think that the color treatment is the most detracting part from this image. I think the lighting choices are interesting.
Post actions
I wish they were interacting more, they just don't look comfortable together. A nice clear photo but not so sure about the yellow tones.
Post actions
nice contrast between the two people,
Post actions
great portrait - try another expression
Post actions
The tones (yellowish on my screen) doesn't go down too well with me. sorry The contrast between the two ladies is nice though, 6
Post actions
Love the contrast here between the old and young person. It's very telling and profound. Well done! 8.
Post actions
I wish they were both looking in the same direction.
Post actions
Nice tones to draw out the contrast between the two subjects.
Post actions
Post actions
I like what you've done here; they are quite captivating and I like how they are not looking at the camera. I'm not really fond of the yellowish tone, perhaps you were going for sepia and it looks yellowish on my monitor. I wonder how this would look with the girl looking at her elder, using more of a profile.
Post actions
Post actions
I wish their poses worked better together.
Post actions
Look like an interesting pair
Post actions
Very nice portrait of the young and the old. I like the use light and dark here.
Post actions
No offense, but just because <- she's old and she's -> young doesn't mean that they really represent "wisdom vs youth".
Post actions
This looks a little to yellow, I would have toned down the saturation a bit more. I find it interesting that they are both staring off the frame but in opposite directions.
Post actions
I wonder if this is grand mother and grand daughter? Nice sepia tones.
Post actions
Post actions
I really like the processing - the duotone is a nice choice, and I love the detail and level of sharpness.
Post actions
nice shot, but in my opinion the light is a little to harsh on the girls face.
Post actions
Incredibly well photographed, I'm thinking your score is making you happy.
Post actions
Good pic but feel that the WB is a little off.
Post actions
An interesting photo, but the lighting is not very strong on the subjects, and neither are making a connection with the viewer. A good concept though.
Post actions
I like the picture, but I would've preferred to see it in black and white without the yellow. Good capture of the two of them though.
Post actions
like the way you converted this to B&W/Sepia...not really sure which...
Post actions
Post actions
wow great shot, the sepia realy works, love the look in the young girls eye
Post actions
I dont know if I really like the sepia for this but I like the idea.
Post actions
without suspecting you of cheating: I have the impression of a collage of two images (I know, it isn't), the two persons don't seem to interact, looks like they are from different worlds; the different amount of light on the two faces enhances the impression.
Post actions
really great idea nicely done
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
