Very good lighting effect and I like the toning. I know it's difficult without editing but this would be improved withought the hotspots (mainly the one on the arm and the one showing through the back left of the chair). Also, compositionally, I think it might have been better to be on the right side of the frame, since the chair is facing left. Still overall, you've achieved the goal of making something mundane extraordinary!
Like the tone and softness of the subject. Not crazy about the huge dark vignette surrouding the chair on the uneveness of the area directly around the chair. Still very nice overall.
Wow, what incredible lighting... it gives a plain old rocking chair an incredibly eerie feeling. What exactly did you use for lighting? Definately one of the week's best.
Painting with light style! It appears that you were not real even with your moving of the light around. THis would explain some of the more (or less) lit areas. Great job none the less! One thing I would think about if you attempt re-shoots... I think the chair would look like it fits better in the frame if it was pointed into the frame rather than out of it.
TC