Author Thread
Post actions
i was one of the five that gave you a nine..i liked it.
Post actions
Thanks to all who voted, and thanks to flip... I agree. I'm no Ansel Adams, but a 1?
Post actions
Yikes ... a one? How on earth can anybody score this with a one? Something is wrong somewhere. Despite the ones, I still think this representation fits the challenge well (and that alone deserves several points), and was executed beautifully.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Nice black & white photo...good contrast.
Post actions
A good idea and effective composition, but I would have liked to see either slightly more or slightly less of her face.
Post actions
this would have been a much stronger shot had the focus been on.
Post actions
Seems a little off focus, but good idea. Maybe just a little too much black
Post actions
Great idea! The pose makes for an interesting composition and the interplay of light and shadow is fascinating. Focus/ image quality let it down.
Post actions
Definitely one of the top for this challenge, I would like to see the origional.
Post actions
The rest of the shot is so low-key that my eye seems stuck on the bright spot- the model's arm. Maybe the model did not want to be visible?
Post actions
Very nice composition. Would have liked to see a little more DOF, but very nice job over all.
Post actions
Overall a bit brighter would have been my preference (via. my monitor). Nice job.
Post actions
Nice little touch with the long hair only revealing a part of her face.
Post actions
Nice idea. You may have been going fro the grainy/slightly blurred look, but I think it's over the top. A slightly more focussed or sharper image would have been better. The treatment given to the image does not do justice to the presumably beautiful long hair. A second weaker light coming in from the left would have given more body to the hair as well. I like the crop and the concept is sound.
Post actions
Good composition, lighting.
Post actions
Think I understand the watereffect but needs to be a litle more lit and also it could be sharper
Post actions
Fantastic : though the rim of the jug and hair are wee out of focus it seems
Post actions
this picture would have been better with the face in it
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
This is a beautifully balanced and pleasing image. Everything works here. 10
Post actions
very nice...black and white works well here...good luck. 10
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
