I like it
don't know what it would look like had you kept a water line, like the equivalent of a horizon, try it who knows, though i guess you were aiming for something disappearing in darkness. Though perhaps if you had a water line it wouldnt have the feel of being so dark that you have the false impression its not as sharp as it really is (cf. comment below)
just a thought.
Very good photograph. I wanted to give it a 10 but IMO the lack of some extra detail in the limb and leaves made me hunt for a better focus area. Still a great shot and deserves a 9 from me.