I knew this was yours. I'm back as I promised to add this to my favorites. It seems that I have no idea what I'm talking about but I still think this should have gotten a ribbon. You never cease to amaze me. I was really surprised with your movie submission. I thought it was excellent and never would have suspected it was yours. I love to see a range in a persons work and your portfolio is a great example.
of the few cloning photos, I think this on eis the best. I like the BW-Color transition and the clone on the left looking up in the sky as if is asking why is nice.
I love this idea and the execution. I do feel that the saturated ring of colour is just along for the ride though! This would have worked without it whichever version you chose. [9]
The clones work out pretty well. The location is generally effective as well. That absurd circle of (oversaturated) color is nearly unforgivable though. It seems very gratuitious and without purpose. I like the tone and effect you had going outside of the circle, and I think leaving the entire shot like that would work much better.
This looks like a really cool place to shoot. Very interesting background, and I like the circle of color. The white shirt is a bit of a distraction - just a little too bright for me. It also bothers me that the right side seems cut off in an odd way.
This should definetely win you another fine ribbon (unless, of course, I have no idea what I'm talking about). I will be adding it to my favorites when the challenge is over. Wonderful art. You have many talents. 10
I think your idea and concept is great. I see a blue cast however which takes away from the photo a little bit -- too much exposure too. The setting however is superb. I like the architectural detail.
Nice montage with beautiful background. Their faces are a little bit oversaturated though. The circular colour separation doesn't do much for me. The whole image would have looked better in the sepia tone as it would have balanced with the old background look. But I still like your image.