| Author | Thread | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/17/2007 05:14:17 AM			 | 
		
		| Wonderful shot - Great capture and colour saturation. A great image to have. |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/04/2007 11:05:28 PM			 | 
		
		Beautiful colors and bird. Perfect composition, depth of field and focus. I would have voted this at 9 without no reservations.
  As for my personal impression, this is of the finest bird images that I have seen. |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/04/2007 08:59:45 PM			 | 
		
		Wow! This is incredible,
 
 Jack |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/07/2006 08:19:27 PM			 | 
		
		| Awesome and I'm sure it's not beginners luck, great shot |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/06/2006 10:44:52 PM			 | 
		
		| Congratulations. An excellent start indeed! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/06/2006 06:37:16 PM			 | 
		
		| Heck of a finish for a first submission :-) Congrats! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/05/2006 10:12:09 PM			 | 
		
		| Wow, awesome colors here. Great capture!  Congrats! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/05/2006 10:32:01 AM			 | 
		
		| Well, don't know if you're a beginner, but this is a masterpiece. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/03/2006 06:56:26 PM			 | 
		
		| beginners luck? very nice! congrats! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/02/2006 02:45:28 PM			 | 
		
		| Amazing ... uncross those fingers and submit to some more challenges! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 09:04:25 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 11:07:11 AM			 | 
		
		Hi Everyone. Thanks for all the kind words. If you are interested... here are some of the out takes / other shots from the challenge:
 //www.pbase.com/kloutit/wildlife_ii__possible_entries |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 10:13:01 AM			 | 
		
		| A beautiful capture. Congratulations on your ribbon! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 10:08:12 AM			 | 
		
		| WOW - a ribbon already??? I'm depressed. ha ha ha ha |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 09:33:16 AM			 | 
		
		| Congrats on a win with your first try.... |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 09:24:44 AM			 | 
		
		| Great job! I had an "aha!" moment when I read the location, I've walked past there on several occasions. Haven't been to SG in a couple years, though... I miss it! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 08:38:59 AM			 | 
		
		| Fantastic photo, congratulations on your ribbon! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 04:32:39 AM			 | 
		
		| So it did ribbon ! I am glad ! Congratulations ! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 03:01:34 AM			 | 
		
		| That is a beautiful shot. congrats! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 02:16:40 AM			 | 
		
		| Beautiful capture of this low flyer!  Congratulations.  An incredible accomplishment to win on your first entry. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 02:06:20 AM			 | 
		
		| Awesome shot, an exceptional first entry. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 01:47:21 AM			 | 
		
		| What a beauty and what colors. Wow! Congratulations on your YELLOW. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 01:34:59 AM			 | 
		
		| wow...so crisp and with rich color tones...hard to pull it all together in an action shot like this...well done! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 01:27:23 AM			 | 
		
		| Beautiful image.  Congrats on a great start to your dpc career.  Now keep it up. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 12:52:11 AM			 | 
		
		Wow A stunning Image
 Congratulations |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
02/01/2006 12:28:42 AM			 | 
		
		| No WAY - your first challenge submission and you ribboned?!  WOW!  Wonderful!  Congratulations...you are one to watch. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
 Comments Made During the Challenge   | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/31/2006 10:50:39 PM			 | 
		
		| Great color...like the (lily pads?) too! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/31/2006 08:46:10 PM			 | 
		
		| Wow!  Such strong contrasting colours!  Great capture too, good luck 10 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/31/2006 08:19:46 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/31/2006 05:17:19 PM			 | 
		
		| 8 - Very nice capture.  Good stop motion.  Criticism; difficult, the lily pads more OOF or sharper (difficult), and maybe a fraction more space above the duck (dependent of course) - and I want to say sharper, even 'more' stop motion, but very difficult, plus I am sure that this size doesn't show the detail larger does.  Coloring, on the duck especially, very good.  Perhaps a variation in cropping.  Not sure on the frame.  Up to 8 from 7. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/31/2006 03:44:58 PM			 | 
		
		| A ribbon-winner for sure.  Good luck! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/31/2006 01:41:11 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/31/2006 11:07:50 AM			 | 
		
		| Beautiful head and colored wing catch |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 10:28:20 PM			 | 
		
		| Wow - this looks like a winner.  The clarity on the duck (I assume it's a duck)  is amazing.  Excellent color, crispness and composition.  Well done.  And a fave. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 08:48:28 PM			 | 
		
		| wow, great capture, the colors of the duck's wing really is set off by the lilly pads. Good focus and DOF. i wouls have liked to see him a bit less cramped up in the corner on the framing, but you get what you get with birds on the wing and this one is a honey. Top ten. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 05:32:33 PM			 | 
		
		| Wonderful combination of flora and fauna, good colors, shapes, sharpness, DOF, and composition.  I especially like the curves of the wings, wing position, feathers, and lilly pads. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 01:25:05 PM			 | 
		
		| Beautiful colors & excellent composition. Nice action shot! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 01:19:57 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 11:21:17 AM			 | 
		
		| Stunning work. Just beautiful! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 08:05:28 AM			 | 
		
		| I love this shot!The colours are beautiful. You have done really well to capture this. Good luck in the challenge!! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 07:23:37 AM			 | 
		
		| I'm so jealous!  A beautiful bird in a lovely location with perfect focus and DOF.  You have caught this spot on.  Certainly a 10 from me. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/30/2006 02:06:56 AM			 | 
		
		| Fantastic shot! The complimentry colors of the bird's wing and the leaves really add to it. I only wish the background were either a bit more blurry or a  little more in focus. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/29/2006 06:01:14 PM			 | 
		
		| What a beautiful duck. I like how well the colors of the bird go against the green background. I gave it a 10. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/29/2006 03:25:12 PM			 | 
		
		| One of the last ones I voted on.  I'm glad I did.  Amazing shot!  10 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/29/2006 02:21:06 PM			 | 
		
		| Great capture of the bird in flight.  Very good color and clarity. Very nice! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/29/2006 11:44:08 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/29/2006 07:27:19 AM			 | 
		
		| One of my top three. Great focus on the parts that need it ... the head. And the lily pads add a colour to the picture that take from good to very good. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/29/2006 03:17:43 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/28/2006 05:11:19 PM			 | 
		
		| Whoah!  Could you have captured a more perfect pose????   I don't think so!  Talk about being in the exact right position, at exactly the right time.  Beautiful sharpness.  Color.   Fantastic job. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/28/2006 01:29:18 PM			 | 
		
		| absolutely beautiful.  nice work. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/28/2006 10:52:59 AM			 | 
		
		| Gorgeous bird.  Love the detail on the wing.  I like the background but would like to see the pic with the background a bit more muted, maybe. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/28/2006 08:12:48 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/28/2006 01:45:01 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/27/2006 08:02:49 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/27/2006 06:52:32 PM			 | 
		
		| Wow, great capture, colors and composition.  Top ten and a favorite from me. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/27/2006 05:24:05 PM			 | 
		
		| Astonishing. The color-mix is impressive. The details are great even if the bird is in flight. Congrats. -9 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/27/2006 04:14:48 PM			 | 
		
		| Great action capture and DOF. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/27/2006 10:07:37 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/26/2006 07:53:07 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/26/2006 05:16:10 PM			 | 
		
		| Excellent shot. IMO one of the best in this challenge and sure to finish up near the top |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/26/2006 12:28:23 PM			 | 
		
		| I find the brightness of the green is distracting.  Otherwise good shot. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/26/2006 09:48:31 AM			 | 
		
		| This is sublime and perfectly captured.  The colors are rich and lush, and the intense expression on the goose (I think its a goose...I know for sure it isn't a deer or a squirrel) adds to the overall effect.  Good luck. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/26/2006 04:36:16 AM			 | 
		
		Captured the grace and beauty of the bird very well here.  Lilly pads are a bit distracting but are necessary to clarify just where the bird was found.  
 
 Nice shot. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/26/2006 12:47:34 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 11:56:56 PM			 | 
		
		| Great shot. Love the colors and the selective sharpness! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 11:34:26 PM			 | 
		
		| Love this shot...the composition and colors are great...nice capture of the duck in flight...background is a tad grainy...awesome shot...great work! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 10:56:21 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 10:24:22 PM			 | 
		
		| Very nice clarity on the bird. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 06:31:37 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 04:06:48 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 04:00:26 PM			 | 
		
		| Cool, definitely one of the better picture in this challenge (9) |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 03:37:38 PM			 | 
		
		| Great Capture; excellent crop |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 03:08:09 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 02:32:42 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 02:00:57 PM			 | 
		
		| This is a really nice shot. I hope you get in the top 5 or better. You get a ten from me. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 01:23:29 PM			 | 
		
		| may be a TAD oversaturated, but may not be, colors just look TOO good, LOL good luck, and think this is a ribboner LOL |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 01:04:20 PM			 | 
		
		| Very nice.  I might have preferred a slightly more shallow DOF, but a very nice catch. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 11:56:16 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 10:24:44 AM			 | 
		
		| Excellent whistling-duck.  Nice timing and colors are wonderful. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 03:04:02 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 01:51:22 AM			 | 
		
		| Fantastic. Deserves a top 5 for sure. Tack sharp, incredible focus, great colours. Congrats. 9 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
01/25/2006 12:16:05 AM			 | 
		
		| I love it.  These flight shots aren't easy. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. |