Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Great use of the shadow to impart the silhoutte feel. The brick texture as it plays in light and shadow is just nice to look at. Bump.
Post actions
Challenge: Sil or Shadowcast? The very question will hurt this image, although technically a sil, in the 'purist's' minds, this will cost you.
Post actions
This is actually a shadow rather than a silhouette. I would suggest adding some other element, as it is right now - there isn't a whole lot to look at. The bricks provide texture and color - but that's about it.
Post actions
This would be a shadow, not a silouette I'm afraid. Sorry!
Post actions
I think I silhouette is a figure that is blackened from the light not a shadow. Nice shadow though.
Post actions
Post actions
This is a shadow? Not a silhouette?
Post actions
Nice picture, I am afraid that this may not do well as the scene is not strictly a silhouette!
Post actions
Sorry, it's a shadow. The subject is supposed to be backlit, not the photographer. 3
Post actions
This isn't a silhouette, it's a shadow. . . two very different concepts.
Post actions
Sorry to see you misunderstand the challenge...good luck next time
Post actions
this is a shadow, not a silohuette, but you probably got this comment before.
Post actions
This is more of a shadow. I think the challenge was to deal with a back lit object.
Post actions
This is a shadow on a wall but not a silhouette photo, so it doesn't meet the challenge in my opinion. Nice shot though!
Post actions
Interesting composition. IMHO shadows don't count as silhouettes. But you've managed to capture a nice clear image here.
Post actions
I don't think a shadow and a silhouette are synonymous
Post actions
IMO, does not meet definition of a silhouette. This is a static and frankly uninteresting photo. Wish I could be more help.
Post actions
More Shadow Than Silloette....5
Post actions
This is a shadow, not a silhouette
Post actions
sorry, a shadow and a sihouette are two totally different things...
Post actions
Post actions
this is a shadow not a silhouette...
Post actions
Post actions
This is more a shadow than a silhouette.
Post actions
In my opinion, shadows are not silhouetts, they are shadows. You can get the same shot in a silhouette, just use a light and a sheet. Try it again.
Post actions
probably more a shadow than silhouette
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
