Composition - I don't have the first clue what you were shooting. I'd like to say it meets the challenge, but I don't know if it meets any challenge aside from abstract. This is a tough one to critique. My first suggestion would be to put clone some of the color from the top right corner and cover the whole image with that color and have some kind of fun abstract from it. Personally, I don't see anything in this image that is worth saving.
Technical - N/A
Overall - I'm not surprised one bit that this finished dead last. I can't find a single redeemable quality about it except that its a very small file and my dialup connection could load it very quickly. Go back to the drawing board and start again. I would like to know what this supposed to be a picture of though. Good luck in future challenges. I think from here, the only way to go is up!! - Inspzil
Gosh I try to say something nice about every picture....I see so little opportunity for praise, how about Lots of negative space.... I honestly don't know what you were going for. I see a heavily pixelated rainbow in the upper right corner and the rest is a pleasant shade of gray. As much as I like gray, I cannot offer this photo any sort of good score. I've never scored below a 3.....(but I feel almost forced to do so). 3 Rob the Swash (please explain this to me...my brain hurts)
Ummm---looks like a shot of a white wall zoomed all the way in to get the pixels huge. Basically, I don't see anything here. If you send me a PM telling me what it is, I'll up your score.
This is a very refreshing change after looking at everything else. Of course, it is also very little. I'd imagine these pixels as part of a series perhaps, for interest and increased credibility?
It's way to abstract, and I like abstract more then most (here anyway). I'll be very interested to see how this does. I'd give this a 6. But I bet the overall will be much lower.
Rothko-esque. :-) I like this, as an image. Not sure it meets my personal criteria of 'photograph', perhaps. Maybe it's Burt Reynolds finally coming round?
I'm not exactly sure what you were trying to show here, but it's especially uninteresting. Add to that bad compression artifacts and you get a low score.. Better luck next time!
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
