Author Thread
11/30/2004 09:57:43 PMPost actions
(unhelpful comment removed by author)
See here Message edited by author 2005-10-05 01:45:05.
Comments Made During the Challenge
11/23/2004 11:26:38 PMPost actions
Doesn't look like black and white to me
11/23/2004 09:47:14 PMPost actions
should have rotated it so the buildings aren't falling.
11/23/2004 11:56:18 AMPost actions
Black and white, not red and white please :)
11/23/2004 11:22:45 AMPost actions
11/23/2004 11:16:58 AMPost actions
Sears Tower in the background? Sadly you are asking for trouble with those strong verticals not being vertical. I like the misty cityscape however
11/23/2004 12:35:40 AMPost actions
Ahhhh... I'm tipping over!
With that exception -- I like the shot :-)
11/22/2004 02:08:10 PMPost actions
11/21/2004 09:28:02 AMPost actions
Just a bit of rotation would have helped. I like the addition of a little red to the shot.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/21/2004 04:44:59 AMPost actions
I have seen other duotone shots in this challenge, and this is one of them. Not technically a "palette of grays" but it isn't a color shot either. It's monocrome. Now I'm in a moral dillemma over voting on this image. Ok: "Sweet shot, but the duotone will bump you down a bit. Seems tilting to the left."
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/20/2004 08:51:04 PMPost actions
Interesting concept! The photo could use a slight rotation to the right.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/20/2004 02:23:37 PMPost actions
The image balance is good... the level does not work for me at all and distracts from what would have been an excelent entry (IMHO). Good luck!
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/19/2004 10:35:22 PMPost actions
Chicago is MY kind of town, but better suited in B&W....
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/19/2004 09:48:03 PMPost actions
This image appears tilted 1-2 degrees counter clockwise.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/19/2004 06:26:54 AMPost actions
First of all, this picture isn't very visually appealing. It is actually tilted to the left. It could have more contrast and it is not Black and White, it is not even sepia, it is pinkish in my monitor.
11/18/2004 10:36:52 PMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/18/2004 02:11:38 PMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/18/2004 09:24:20 AMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/18/2004 02:12:13 AMPost actions
Maybe it's my monitor (I doubt it cuz no one elses photo is) but this looks brown. I'm also not a fan of the 'diagonal' composition. Seems very point-and-shoot. 3
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 10:56:18 PMPost actions
I don't think this classifies as palette of grays. A nice shot, but would have fit the challenge better without the tone.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 10:43:58 PMPost actions
Looks like Chicago. South side?
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 09:50:18 PMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 07:14:12 PMPost actions
Kinda sepia but I like the fogginess.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 06:13:49 PMPost actions
Unlevel horizon really detracts from this image. Use of Sepia has hugely improve the otherwise lack of foreground contrast though. Excellent choice. 7.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 04:28:07 PMPost actions
hmm not totally black and white
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 04:10:03 PMPost actions
I like the framing and the tint of the photo, but I think the 2 buildings in the foreground are tilting to the left
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 04:01:22 PMPost actions
This looks like a snapshot as there is no clear cut focal point---nothing that my eye immediately recognized as the subject of the iamge. This could use a contrast boost as well as a rotation make the verticals parallel. An interesting view that you should go back to to reshoot.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 01:54:25 PMPost actions
A little crooked for my taste, but great subject.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 01:36:34 PMPost actions
Sorry I'm not sure about the toning and unfortunately the verticals are - well, not! 4
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 12:38:06 PMPost actions
Cool idea to use the two buildings to frame the skyline. I'd like to see more of the city and less of the sky. Perhaps either more sepia or less color; it looks like you couldn't decide which.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 11:46:40 AMPost actions
The tilted horizon takes away from an otherwise interesting shot
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 11:43:41 AMPost actions
things are tilted, very distracting.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 10:34:04 AMPost actions
Nice picture but I would have rotated the picture a few grades to right.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 02:52:45 AMPost actions
The horizon seems out of alignment - it would have been good to rotate this a bit.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 02:18:05 AMPost actions
Black and white is not brown. and also, horizon is tilted. I have to give it a 1.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 01:42:52 AMPost actions
Looks different from all other entries for this comp... :)
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 12:56:27 AMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/17/2004 12:19:27 AMPost actions
I don't see black, and there is no white, and what is with all the brown stuff?
Photographer found comment helpful.