Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
That star is appealing. I think a 6.0
Post actions
With only the sunstar as the major feature, I think you will not get more than 5.1.
Post actions
The sunburst is great - so sharp and clean. The subject does not interest me. I gave it a five; predict a 5.4
Post actions
Post actions
Love the starburst of the sun. The B&W works well too. 5.5
Post actions
lol. can't hurt to hope. I guess 4.7
Post actions
Interesting guess! I think you'll be about a 4.5.
Post actions
I like the starburst. But the rest of the photo looks to flat too me where the tree meets the sky. I'll guess 6.3
Post actions
Post actions
A bit optimistic which I like. Not a very interesting photo
Post actions
Post actions
It is a very nice photograph but I give you a 6 sorry miss something to catch my eyes.
Post actions
For me, this image is a good one, but one notch below the best images in the challenge. I expect it to do about 5.5
Post actions
Simply stated. Like the starburst. 5.1
Post actions
I think you may be a bit optimistic 5.2
Post actions
I gave it a five. Guessing a 5.8
Post actions
Although the whole looks somewhat grey, it's a very nice star-shaped sun 5.12
Post actions
My guess: 6.03 for detail and tones and that Canon f/22 starburst. I keep trying but my Nikon lenses don't seem to do it in this way I find so appealing.
Post actions
I'm a huge fan of sun stars - they add something to less interesting pictures. But I'm missing the colour of the sky in this -5 from me and I predict 4.8
Post actions
this is a great shot with a really high f-stop. great ( one draw back of the high f stop is the sensor spots that show, you should clean your sensor ) great crop with the sun in a good spot,and well defined silhouette. I can't agree with your score prediction because of the sensor spots not removed, this has potential but I predict a score below six about 5.8 Good Luck
Post actions
gotta love a dreamer. I like the texture created by all those branches, so six from me. DPC will give you a straight up 5
Post actions
Good shot. But I guess it will be a 5.60
Post actions
Perfect starburst/sunburst in the tree. Bonus point for that from me (I know how hard it is to get those just right), but the rest of the image is rather ordinary, so I think you guessed high. 5.89
Post actions
no no,,,this ends 4+ my guess,,,,,5 from me
Post actions
Beautiful sun flare. 5.47
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
The light is nice, but that's about all. 5.6
Post actions
lofty goal
Post actions
Nice star! I estimate a final score of 5.1
Post actions
Really 8.1 NO WAY, pretty sure you know that ;p)
Post actions
I like the sunburst but I think your prediction is somewhat optimistic. Six from me, predicting 5.775.
Post actions
I like that you've retained detail in the darks; wouldn't mind it just a smidge more contrast-y... 5.78
Post actions
I voted before looking at titles, now commenting.
Post actions
It's okay. I like the sun coming through the trees. A 5
Post actions
I am guessing in the high 4's, 4.8 for this for dpc... I voted a five, to me its a bit dark and I love seeing details in trees when shots like these are made
Post actions
Great detail and nice starburst like flare. 5.3
Post actions
5.8657 (I gave it a seven)
Post actions
Post actions
5 Maybe I'm shallow but I need a more interesting portrayal of nature. Also, the upper left patch of sky seems to have a few sensor spots.
Post actions
Nice star burst. I predict 5.3.
Post actions
nothing will get this over 3.8967
Post actions
Hello, I voted a few days ago, now returning for comments. I think that you over estimated your final score, even if this is one of my top five in this Challenge and I gave you a eight, I predict that you will finish at 6.337 and it should be a top ten.
Post actions
Cool sun burst but after that, well it kind of falls flat.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
