"Hey Schmitty, how about some O2 over here!"
by Nald

Comment:
Several things seem to be a little off in this one. The skin tones on the model are just a bit too redish/pinkish. (I hate skin tones myself...) The composition looks a litte awkward. The model isn't on a third line or centered but just a bit off from center. This may look more natural if he weren't looking out of the frame. I'm assuming that you placed him in this position to capture the moonbuggy in the shot. Turning him the other way may have helped...
TC

Famine
by Tranquil

Comment:
I don't know why, but something just doesn't look right about this shot. I've come back 4 or 5 times to try and figure it out but can't. I THINK it's the harsh shadow going right up the center of the shot and enveloping the main subject.
TC

Fire and Ice
by tooter

Comment:
This looks like it is just a tad crooked. Could be the perspective though...
TC

Winter Refuge
by hahn23

Comment:
I would not call having to wake up and see a scene like this harsh, but can see how it can fit the challenge! :-P Nice entry.
TC

freezing rain
by ralph

Comment:
Nice and simple! Nothing blown out which is always a good thing. Background could be a bit less blah in color but it is what it is.
TC

Burned out Train Engine Factory
by grainman9

Comment:
Like the lines in this. Definatly fits the challenge. Only thing I don't like and could be fixed easily I'm told (I never could figure it out...)j is the perspective. It's not fish eye off which would actually look good, it's annoying off. If you don't know what I mean, it's how the building looks like it's leaning in on itself...
TC

don't jump
by skewsme

Comment:
LOL... I didn't even see the cat till I came back to comment on the shot. This is not exactly a photogenic scene, but fits the challenge well and doesn't seem to be overly manipulated like some...
TC

gr_tavern_04-16-06_800-199k.jpg
by LanceW

Comment:
The tonality and detail work of this shot are incredible. It's simply laden with details that work together and do not look busy!
Kudos
TC

Engulfment Hazard
by posthumous

Comment:
This is very busy. It is good that you used a square crop for this otherwise within the constraints of allowable screen real estate you would have a mish mash of details. As it is it's just too busy. It confuses the eye. It doesn't know where it's supposed to end up.
TC

Lake Superior in December
by shamer

Comment:
Looks like an overly enthusiastic use of a new tool... Too saturated to appear realistic.
TC