Recovered Marshes
by zeuszen

Comment:
Just an observation...It's been a long time since I looked through NG but I don't recall any shots that were at an angle such as this one. Nice shot overall...
TC

Right before my best buddy's head fell off for Makro III
by Harz_Joerg

Comment:
From the Critique Club

This is a very unique shot for the challenge. I love the use of the mirror that gives an effect similar to a wide angle lens. The focal point and DOF are dead on. Combining with the fish eye effect, this gives an almost dreamlike feel!

There are a couple of nit picky minor things compositionaly that I don't like. There is some kind of artifact on the lower left curve of the mirror that is a touch distracting. The image isn't cropped evenly on the left and right in relation to the circle of the mirror.

I know some people may not have liked the added elements (tissues and filter), but I think that they only add to the illusion of someone working hard to get the 'perfect macro' shot!

Nice job
TC

Parking Lot Stop
by iloveguam

Comment:
I don't like psychedelic...
TC

My past is fading, my present is clear, but my future is obscured
by AmiYuy

Comment:
My original comment (though maybe a little harsh) still stands. I like the shot in general. I DID make an assumption that the photographer (You, Ami) had more controll over the shot! Anytime that anyone with our camera has a shot that they think is worth entering is IMHO an accomplishment! Good job Ami!

My past is fading, my present is clear, but my future is obscured
by AmiYuy

Comment:
I like everything about this shot except the extremely shallow DOF and the title....
TC

Step up-Step down
by justine

Comment:
That's GOT to be casino carpeting...
TC

Home
by johnm

Comment:
I really like this one for some reason. For all it's plainess, it DOES make me feel like home. Not my home, but somewhere that I could spend some comfort time!
TC

Synchronicity
by crabappl3

Comment:
Too much border...
TC

Under a Palm
by Nukkta

Comment:
You used a flash didn't you...
TC

My Little Chickadee
by vtruan

Comment:
Looks underexposed and like the white balance is wrong...
TC