Platten and Desnoyers, Dog's Corner of the World
by mnast

Comment:
Initial=a little funny
Composition=unusual, although the sidewalk actually creates some interesting diagonals.
Clarity (focus, details)=maybe was out of focus and then oversharpened?
Exposure=Perhaps over exposed, or colors oversaturated
Interesting or Emotive=only for a short while.

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

Corner Shelf
by undieyatch

Comment:
Initial=interesting geometrics
Composition=like how the red triangle points up to the shelves above, which are also in a triangular position
Clarity (focus, details)=Starts out well from the bottom, but due to the darkness at the top, the image becomes dithered. Perhaps some lighting at the top of the shelf would eleviate this.
Exposure=fair
Interesting or Emotive=the geometrics are interesting, but the plastic bag stops my eye from continuing to the top. The other items on the shelf are fine.

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

My corner of the world has no sharp edges...
by fsieradzki

Comment:
Initial=wonderful!
Composition=horizon is a bit too centered
Clarity (focus, details)=excellent.
Exposure=well done.. but could be a bit more red from the sunset.
Interesting or Emotive=the interest in this photo comes from the movement of the waves. You caught them brilliantly.

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

City of Bridges
by sohr

Comment:
Initial=This is a beautiful image..
Composition= good. bridge leads my eye into the photo and to the distant buildings. I wonder about the top of the image crowding the tops of the buildings. Perhaps a bit more room could have been allowed there and less on the bottom
Clarity (focus, details)= excellent. I love how I can see every little window, and how the lights reflect on the water.
Exposure=well done.
Interest=This holds my interest.

I am using this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

Coal Train Out Of Commission
by #1 Bronco Fan

Comment:
Initial=very nice!
Composition=excellent
Clarity (focus, details)=love the feeling of infinity into the distance
Exposure=well done. great sky, too.
Interesting or Emotive=holds interest.

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

Chord
by johnson

Comment:
Initial=fabulous!
Composition=well done
Clarity (focus, details)=great use of DOF
Exposure=some hot spots, but good overall tones.
Interesting or Emotive=very emotive. good job.

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

Window on Sleeping Suburbia
by DougPaz

Comment:
very good!

A Touch of Gold
by rumttugger

Comment:
Initial=very artistic
Composition=excellent
Clarity (focus, details)=superb
Exposure=excellent
Interesting or Emotive=both.. this is grand!

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb

Digital Photograph
by DigiPique

Comment:
An analogy to pixel wells? Hmmm. Creative!

Eastern Point of Australia
by vitsmak

Comment:
Initial= great sunburst
Composition=well done.. although the horizon seems a bit slanted to me.
Clarity (focus, details)=good focus and clarity deep into the photo.
Exposure=well done.
Interesting or Emotive=sunsets are always emotive to me.. Helps me feel peaceful.

I am using a this new detailed commenting method inspired by autool. (Thanks
autool!). I hope you find it more helpful than my former comments.
Thanks for submitting, and good luck! ;0)
kpb