Illuminated Everlasting Flowers
by Doylie

Comment:
I found this composition a bit odd. I couldn't quite figure out what the foil wrapped thing was at the left. It is an obvious light source but I don't think it enhances this photo.

LoveLights
by soheil

Comment:
This is a little bit overlit in my opinion. There is very little detail in the shadow and highlight areas of the doll. There is good separation between the subject in the background although it is a bit two-dimensional. As a subject, I don't find this doll too compelling (she is a little creepy looking to me)Other's might though. Good luck!

Bright
by rockfish

Comment:
I think one of the obvious light sources was flash. This looks like an image that has been washed of detail because of close-up, front flash. This isn't the best approach to the subject matter which depends on color and texture for its visual appeal.

persevering delusion
by xburnerx

Comment:
I looked and looked at this photo and I just couldn't quite get what you were going for. I'll describe what I see....A shadow that looks something like a rhinoceros wearing a hat with two blue spots of light where the nostrils would be...and a high heel shoe. I'm pretty sure I'm way off base.
The title didn't enlighten me. I think my problem is once I saw the shadows the way I described I couldn't see anything else. Sorry...

The Flag in the 'Old Arcade'
by bobdaveant

Comment:
This is actually quite a good interior, architectural shot. I would ignore the ones, twos, and threes---wierdness. Your subject is quite obviously centered so there is no real exuse for giving this photo less than a five. I probably would have scored it higher than five personally. I didn't vote on all the centered challenges and didn't see this one.

My Way
by Imagineer

Comment:
I really like the simple colors in this. The turquoise and the boy's blond curls haromize beautifully. Add the sharp shadow and the boy's purposeful stride and it is perfect.

Go Fly a Kite
by StevePax

Comment:
Another nice Centered entry I didn't see. IMO this should have placed higher. Nice job.

scrap
by jus6681

Comment:
This is a beauty. I wish I had voted on all the Centered entries because I missed some very good shots. This has such a feel of traditional photography to it. I hope you make it available as a print.

Message edited by author 2004-05-30 19:25:10.

Foggy Road Home
by Pedro

Comment:
This was one of my picks for a ribbon. I didn't get a chance to comment during the voting though.

Eggs and Morning Dew
by mocabela

Comment:
I loved this shot. I didn't see it until after the voting. I didn't vote on all the Centered entries.