Uh Oh !
by kopa21

Comment:
*Critique Club*

What a cute photo. I know you already know about resizing and how this one was just to small.

Your focus is really good and the lighting is a little to dark, but easily fixed.

Overall I would tend to agree it leaves a few questions and I can hear the child saying uh oh myself.

Anna

Hill 88
by MrBlandAverage

Comment:
Critique Club

I think better lighting here and not leaving so much of a mystery might have helped your score out a bit. Its just to dark for most people to be able to form an opinion on the image.

I will admit though it does meet the challenge well cause as said in comments What is it?

Anna

Grab
by jimmythefish

Comment:
*Critique Club*

I will admit this one makes me laugh. Hot tub that is covered, hand coming out for the beer. So the real question is...Where you to lazy to take the cover off? LOL

Now being serious this is a cute and very creative take on the challenge. Your focus looks really good the lighting is just fine. And the texture of the wood really adds to this who photo.

So why didn't you take the cover off?

Anna

God's Plan?
by mbardeen

Comment:
*Critique Club*

This definately leaves me with one real question and you also said it Why?

You had fantastic texture here. The focus is really good. The lighting works well here, it helps create the feeling you get as you realize a child was taken.

Overall it is a very nice shot.

Anna

Emma G. Nation
by autool

Comment:
Dick you had me thinking this was something else, but looks like I wasn't alone on that. Nice use of your imagination. =o)

Zero spot editing. How?
by kiwiness

Comment:
*Critique Club*

Fantastic photo. Its hard to actually do a critique on. I think the extent you went to, to get this is great. The photo is not only an attention getter but it also is a work of art in itself.

Your blue is such a pretty shade, the focus is really good. The entire concept of how you did it is really neat. There isn't a thing I would change in this image for a challenge but I might touch it up slightly along the seam before printing it. Get rid of the rough spot in the seam to the right of the glass and make it a prefect print.

Anna

I used to be white UNTIL
by ladpupmoe

Comment:
Critique Club

At first glance I am thinking you used some ketchup on that ball. No matter what you did it is very different effect. I am sure you took the photo of the ball as it was moving and the biggest issue with that is the ball is slightly out of focus, possibly an unsharpening mask might have helped with this.

The composition isn't bad the idea is definately there and it obviously meets the challenge.

Anna

The Floater
by RiderGal

Comment:
*Critique Club*

It's definately an interesting image. Can't decide which works better with it they way you have it or if it would have worked better cropping everything out but your Mom and letting it appear as if she was floating in mid air.

Not matter which you would do it still leaves some unanswered questions about the photo.

I am guessing this was a pond and that is how you got the water so dark. Your focus here is really good not only are your toes in focus so is your Mom.

It really is a cool interuptation for the challenge. Nicely done.

Anna

Marble Madness
by Turbotech

Comment:
Nice to see this one. =o)

Perfect vision
by pitsaman

Comment:
The detail here is beautiful. Wonderful use of dof. How close were you to get this? I got to say it is a 10 just cause of the wonderful rainbow effect you captured in the birds neck.