Window on Government
by falvey

Comment:
First, I have to say I liked this photo right away, the first place my eyes went to was the green "starry sky" in the middle of the dome. I also noticed how well it was focused and how the lighting was perfect.
After that I began to see ways this might have been a better photo. Was there any way to avoid the wood section at the top of the photo? It seems to distract. Was there a way to get a wider angle of the dome? Maybe to get all of the dome in the photo instead of part of it. I don't know, maybe your camera would not accomadate that, or maybe it was just not your intention. Overall a nice shot, I would have been proud if it had been mine.

Stone Oranges
by zadore

Comment:
Ok, Phil, I hope you don't get too upset with me, remember, I can only give my opinion, and if I offend, it's not my intent. A couple people commented that the oranges seem to be the subject, not the tile, I have to agree with them. The photo does fit our theme for the competition, but just barely. Also, the subject of OPA was brought up, and I think that person had a good point. Your shot of the tile did not add anything to what somebody else had already done. Somebody commented that the whole image was not in focus, I don't see that. I did go check out your other photos at your profile and I know you are much capable of much better work. I hope some of my comments will be helpful to you!

My Exotic Pet
by CreativeFlyPhoto

Comment:
Nice photo, but it's not all that cliche! (lol)

Curves
by Natasha

Comment:
Nice texture, the lighting is a little too dark for my taste.

Kit tea (pun)
by Bullwinkle

Comment:
Your cat should submit this to "The mirror project".

Bahsworth & Brodamire
by Gotcha

Comment:
Best doggone photo of them all! Nice portrait.

Sunset
by Frank Beckman

Comment:
I like the effect of the branches in the foreground. Nice pic.

A Very Cliché Shot in Punxsutawney
by alanfreed

Comment:
Extremely cliche! I gotta love this photo. Did you try to take the redeye out of the fellow second from the left? That would've helped.

Wish You Were Here....
by krets

Comment:
Would rate photo higher, but it is so dark at the top. Nice try!

Dear FHM magazine ...
by d95vette

Comment:
Very.....cliche.