rim job
by jbruno1397

Comment:
Light is a bit sharp. But that is ok. The background looks nice.

Food?
by anireno

Comment:
Ok. Is this the hand of a baby or a small person. Notice the fingernails. They kind of look groomed. As far as the idea of Food. I do not know about that. LOL Very sharp.

Dare to Be Different
by karmat

Comment:
Ok. Now this green ball is a bit out of place I would say. I think you are a bit too close for the lens that you are using. This kind of reminds me of the movie "The Attack of the Killer Tomatoes." What is in the background?

Cookie-Puss
by alternarule

Comment:
This is a cute shot. Very sharp. Besides it is making me hungry. Light is a bit bright, but I assume you used the cam flash. It meets the round challenge. I do not know what I would have tried here. Something way different.

Be gentle -- first sub
by sn4psh07

Comment:
Intresting lines. I do however feel that the viewpoint could be changed to serve this focal point a little better. Lighting is a bit harsh. I would personally back away and Turn slightly to the left or right and put the wheel at one of the four quadrants. That woudl dramatically change the composition and effectively please the eye a little bit more. You are on to something here.

Pebbles
by jimmythefish

Comment:
Does the shot fit the Challenge (6)
Photo Color (6)
Composition(4)
Focus(7)
Background(3)
Lighting(4)

Conclusion:
I believe this does fit the challenge with some respect. I do feel however that there were better formations you could have tried. The color is vibrant and I would say accurate. Focus on this shot is very sharp and that is one of ist particular strong points. Background does not really exist so it causes a bit of an eyestrain. The lighting is a bit harsh. Was this taken outside or inside.


Overall Score(5)

golf ball
by jimmyn4

Comment:
Does the shot fit the Challenge (8)
Photo Color (3)
Composition(3)
Focus(4)
Background(4)
Lighting(3)

Conclusion:
The Theme is round and you have captured that here. I would say that I think the color is not very good and that may be due to poor white balance choice. You took this shot from an wierd perspective and I think it does not suit well. One of the only times you will ever hear me say go wider angle. I do not know what you were trying to achieve with this focus but it is very soft. The background in itself can barely be seen so there is not contrast. The lighting is nothign to write home about. Looks like Normal house lighting. For something like this I woudl have tried to suspend the ball and make it look like it was just levitating. I guess I am just a weakling for special effects.

Overall Score(4)

Blue like water
by KissakiMan

Comment:
1)Does the shot fit the Challenge? I would say yes (5)
2)Photo Color: Color is decent(5)
3)Composition: I think the composition is a little week here. (4)
4)Focus: Focus on the Focal point seems to be good.(6)
5)Background. (4)
6)Lighting. Lighting is what really hurt you. (3)


Conclusion:

I think the biggest issue with this shot is the lighting. I think a bit more light at would allow for you to read the bottom of the water Jug. I do however think that you had an idea here. It could have been executed a little better in my oppinion.

Overall Score: 4.5 Rounded to 5.0



John (TurboTech)

Sitting Around
by EddyG

Comment:
Very intresting. Color is crisp and clear. Depth is good. I like

Just Fooling (ROUND)
by margie

Comment:
There is a wonderful sense of Humor in this shot. I like it.