Pumpkins go better with Coca-Cola
by pottersclay75

Comment:
The carving is excellent. Very cool with nice highlights in the carving in nice places. The photo is okay, although I would have liked for the bottle to have been a Coke bottle rather than a beer bottle. JMO.

Space Monkey
by soup

Comment:
Good job on the carving. Good points there. The photo itself feels, to me, to be okay. The composition is a pretty basic, the lighting is good along with good exposure.

Oh, Nooooooo! (the Scream)
by lynnesite

Comment:
Ithink this is the only one with hands ... creative carving to capture The Scream. Th low perspective of the photo accentuates the looking up feel. Good stuff

Always Having To Juggle My Emotions
by Coley

Comment:
Cool image. Smart work on making all the faces different. Nice job on the coposition of the final image.

Jack
by MudHut

Comment:
Great eyebrow carving. Gives Jack a bit of a wicked look!!! I like the light painting with the sparkler. Overall, a cool shot. Good work on the exposure levels/processing. Nothing looks over-exposed.

The Peril of Peter Pumpkin
by KaDi

Comment:
Good work for both the carving and the photo. Definitely a unique set up. I like the bubles on the pumpkin and the magnification factor of the water. If I had a little nit to pick it would be that the top of the photo is a little too bright for my liking. Overall good work.

Wacky the Pumpkin and His Pet Ghost
by Marc923

Comment:
Great carving. The photo is good, but I think it would have been a little more pleasing if you had not placed the top of the ghost at the same level as the top of the pumpkin. Generally speaking, I find compositions to e more pleasing when things aren't on the same level. This is a design rule regarding portraits with 2 or more people, bt I think it applies here too. JMO.

Close Encounter
by davidus428

Comment:
I rally like this type of photo. For me, I would have liked to have seen a stronger silhoutte of the frog. Not sure if that means a sronger light source or not.

Samara
by kiwiness

Comment:
I think you've done a very good job with your transparetn desktop shot.

Nature's gold
by nico_blue

Comment:
Overall, a nice photo. The focus s good and the composition is pleasing. I think that you could have gotten away with a slightly brighter lighting setup ... I think it might have really brought out the veining in the fruit and made the colours just a bit brighter. JMO.