Xylem
by bandit

Comment:
The good: Great idea. The focus plane is sharp:
To work on: The vignette in the corner detracts as does the out of focus portion. Use a deeper DOF.

Transparent Ripples
by MattO

Comment:
The good: creative.
To work on: 1) the top of the splash is cut off. 2) The reflections detract (use a polarizer), 3) The ripples just happened to distort the face a little too much (this is just a matter of repitition and picking the best one).

Samara
by kiwiness

Comment:
Been done before, of course, but this is well executed. Was Samara the name of the girl in The Ring? Man that movie creeped me out. Your attempt at looking like her (if this is indeed what you're going for) was great too. The only criticism is the background. Why did you pick the stairs? They don't add to the atmosphere. 7

I See You, Grumpy Ol' Fish
by SandyP

Comment:
The good: interesting perspective on the fish, the water distorted it in an interesting way.
To work on: the rest of the picture isn't too inspiring. You did about as much as you could with this shot, but your subject keeps you from soaring.

Windows
by flip89

Comment:
I like it. If I'm being really picky I clone out the people on the left and I use a polarizer to remove the mild reflections in the windows. Good capture though. 7

trapped in the bubbles
by suemack

Comment:
The good: creative.
To work on: it's always nice to keep an eye unobstructed. Could you have composed with her eye right in one bubble? The lighting isn't very exciting.

Room with a view
by KiwiChris

Comment:
Heh, I almost did a shot like this. Good for both of us I didn't. If I have one complaint, it's the fish looks a bit washed out. 8

There You Are
by JPR

Comment:
I like this one. That "ghost" is just right. Very faint, yet noticeable. Oh, I just noticed the other ghost (the one sitting). That one is perhaps a little too dim as I almost missed it. 8

red veil
by arngrimur

Comment:
The Good: creative, in a way I like the red tint.
To work on: The red is not kind on her face, mainly her left cheek. The crease right over her eye is also not optimal.

Window to Her Wondrous Soul
by lynnesite

Comment:
ha, I'm happy I guessed it was you. Sorry to harsh on you about the grain, but this picture should be one you are proud of. It's a great shot.