Pear
by KarenB

Comment:
good lighting, decent subject, decent photo with limited appeal. 5 wingy

Lucent Kiwi
by elgomin

Comment:
great idea. a larger reflective surface might have made it even cooler. 9 wingy

Wrongfully Accused
by lmhr

Comment:
Excelent composition, great shadows, great background. I don't know what that black thing behind the fork is though. All around great shot. 9 wingy

Cat and Candle
by jboling

Comment:
the cat isn't lit well enough. the subject is uninteresting. the reflection just looks blurry and dull, so it ends up not adding to the shot. 3 wingy

The Grim Reaper
by Niten

Comment:
= ) I like it. The text from the back was a nice touch. 9 wingy

Evil Wizard
by ScottL

Comment:
wow.. awesome shot. It's slightly difficult to see the small figure, and if this weren't in the current challenge I might suggest a subtle light on him so that he showed up better... but given the single light requirement, this is excelent. 9 wingy

clam by torchlight
by fluffy

Comment:
shot isn't clear enough to tell what the subject is (aside from the title). The table detracts from the shot. 3 wingy

Young Samurai
by Gekker

Comment:
The subject seems uninteresting to me, and it seems too cluttered to be effective in this sort of minimalistic lighting. In technical terms not a bad shot, but it comes across with little appeal. 4 wingy

Candle-Glow
by ppritche

Comment:
So-so profile shot.. not particularly interesting (the expression doesn't have any impact on me at all), but not all bad. 4 wingy

thoughts alone
by takethat

Comment:
too dark.. a brighter light would have made the colors stand out more and the shadows on the table much more effective and drawing. Also I'm not sure if I like the pose of the guy in back and the parts of him that are shown, cut out. Perhaps a little bit more complete view of him, or an even more minimalistic suggestion of his presence. Good idea, but the technical side needed some work. 5 wingy