The Angler
by ZeppKash

Comment:
For a sport photograph, this is very artistic.

There is this guideline for sport photography, and basically you have gone against all the rules.

However, photographically speaking, this is a great image. And, sometimes, as I have found, being artistic, ignoring rules can be a good thing.

Comp is good, but I think there is a bit too much negative space above. Silhouette is excellent, light great, texture great, excellent movement, emotional value great, overall I predict top 10.

Lunch Break
by samanwar

Comment:
comp good, dof in sport photography should be shallower as to be able to focus just on the athlete. The fan in the middle bg is unwanted as is the cars.

The tonal value sucks. The blacks are way too deep, and the whites are blown out.

Light good, movement good, rule of 6 observed, over all could be a great image if just only.....

Julius Rop, last years Rhine-Marathon winner, disappointed
by h2

Comment:
I just critiqued a similar image to this one, and this one is way better.

Here you have focused on one athlete do to your shallow dof.

The rule of 6 is observed, and the crop is tight.

comp great, movement great, whites a blown, blacks a bit deep, excellent light, tonal value great, emotional value excellent, over all I predict a ribbon.

Marathon
by bubeltrubel

Comment:
this is an ok image.

There is this guideline for photography, and one of the guides states the "rule of six".

The rule simply is this...don't have more than 6 athletes in the same image because it starts to get crowded.

Not only is the rule of 6 ignored in this image, but, a sports photograph should be about the athlete meaning tight crops, shallow depth of field, blah, blah.

Comp could be tighter, light good, texture good, blacks just a bit deep, whites just a bit blown, too busy, eye movement poor, over all just an ok image.

Chess with a twist - Shots of Tequila
by heavyj

Comment:
Ok, again as I have said to someone else with a similar image...I guess in some countries chess is considered a sport.

HOWEVER, sports also requires a human presence, especially in sports photography. NOT just props.

Your title says tequila. I see empty glasses. I am not convinced.

comp good, excellent lighting, crisp shot, color just ok, blacks a bit deep, and whites blown, over all a boring image.

Tractor pull
by see

Comment:
Ok, it's a tractor pull. I get it.

But, what I am always seeing first is those advertisements.

theres this guideline to sports photography, and one of the big NO NO's is just what you have done.

This image should be about the truck, the horse power, and the tork it is using to pull that damn tractor.

Through this image, I should be hearing the growl of the engine.

But, the advertisements are keeping me from doing so. They are highly distracting. Also, the bg with the truck wheels and the legs chopped off from smoke is unwanted as well.

Again, it is about the truck and not about the fans.

comp could be better, light ok, color excellent, barely can see the stop action, blacks and whites on the edge of bad and ok, nice texture, dof too sharp for what I just explained to you.

Stealing Is Wrong
by phirewire

Comment:
I have a feeling that this image does not comply to the basic rule set.

great comp, but why do I care? I don't. You are not giving me any reason to care for these players. To cheer for which ever player.

There faces are not seen so the emotional value is poor.

they are just standing there with there back side in my face, so the capture is poor, lighting flat, great texture, color nice, selective desat nice.

dof too sharp for sport photography. A shallow dof is almost a requirement in sports because it is about the player and not the fan and it most definetly is not about the advertisements. Over all a boring image.

Don't give up, just do better.

Ready to Go
by Perfect-Calamity

Comment:
Ok, I get it, it is a track.

Why should I care? You are giving me nothing.

comp ok, color ok, great lines, ok dof, light flat, shadow distracting, great texture, overall boring

Flight
by mpeters

Comment:
there is this guideline for sports photography, and you did almost everything correctly except one very important feature...the emotional value.

I don't want to see her back side. I want to see the face. What she is going through. I want you the photographer to have me share her emotion, not the crack in her ass.

Comp could be tighter, color excellent, light excellent, capture great, emotional value poor, texture good, skin tones excellent, the pole either needs to go, or give me more, right now it is kind of distracting and almost erotic. Overall, keep trying

Two Knights Defense (56) -White to Move
by whiterook

Comment:
I guess in some other countries, chess is a sport.

Too me however, a sport needs humans, not just props.

With that in mind, why should I care for this image? I don't play chess, so it is confusing, and cluttered.

Comp could be better, color yuck, too much to look at and figure out, some texture, light flat, blacks too deep, whites not there, overall a boring image