Conceptual Dilemma
by MichaelC

Comment:
I don't get it. What's the dilemma? To use white or yellow? Hmmm. Oh well. As for the image, the composition is ok, lighting is alright. Something looks unusual in the post-processing as I'm seeing what may be alot of compression artifacts (various layers of white and yellow areas, heavy around the egg yolk and then in the upper-left corner). Could be this cruddy monitor here at work. :D Anyway, just some observations and obviously JMO. Good luck in the challenge.

How White Do You Want It ?
by krgl

Comment:
Cute, I think. It's certainly light on white, but not a very appealing subject to use. JMO of course. Good luck.

Fa La La
by dahkota

Comment:
Very nice holiday theme used here. Good attention to detail in laying this out. Only minor complaint from me is the image in general has a bluish cast to it, like the color temp/white balance is off some. Good luck in the challenge.

Ivory Cat
by bryantbus

Comment:
Wonderful lighting and detail in this photo. Nice job of getting a white background (for the most part) in place for this. Only minor complaint I have is the composition; it would be stronger if the cat wasn't centered, and if both ears were included. Last, and certainly a very, very minor point - if you are going to use your pet as a subject a little extra attention to details like grooming might help a little (fur under the chin is kind of matted and would look nicer combed out). I know, I know...it's a cat, but still. :D Best of luck to you in the challenge.

Pure Holidays
by jfwolpert

Comment:
This is a nice holiday concept type shot. Looks very stockish (which is fine). The lighting on the ornaments is nice and I like the blue tint. The thing holding this back for me is that you don't have a white background. Why not? It would have been fairly easy to do with the subject material you used. Hmmm. Anyway, best of luck to you in the challenge.

Daisy on White
by tfarrell23

Comment:
I like the yellow/green glow here. That's a nice touch. The flower, especially the center, is nice and sharp. Given the impact the center of this flower adds, I would have pushed the background to a truer white. As is, it looks a bit dingy in comparison and takes away from the overall impact a little. All JMO of course. :D Good luck in the challenge.

Natural beauty
by Ragga2000

Comment:
This is one of the better flower shots I've seen in this challenge thus far. I like that you added the green leaf and kept the stem as this helps to offset the white flower from the white (yes, it's actually white - hooray!) background. Good detail and you didn't blow it out. Nicely done. Good luck in the challenge.

Treasures
by SJCarter

Comment:
Very good details on the foreground starfish. I understand your use of DOF to make the background shell an item of interest but not the primary. The big thing that holds this back for me is the seam from wall to floor (back to bottom, however you want to label it...). Best of luck to you in the challenge.

CAT
by rtscribbs02

Comment:
This is cute. I do wish that the background was closer to white instead of beige. Your cat is certainly curious. Well, I guess they all are aren't they, especially at that age. :D Good luck in the challenge.

vive la difference
by ralph

Comment:
Ok, you lured me in from the thumbnail...had to take a look. :D I like the use of the chalks here, very creative. Great use of lighting to get the extremes on the left and base. Almost looks like clouds or fog rolling thru your photo. So, how'd you get them to stand up? I used some of these once and it was a pain to keep them in place. Used playdough on the bottom, which was fine until the playdough starting drying and hardening, then the little buggers would fall over. In your case you'd have some serious "dominos" going on! :D Good luck in the challenge.