Family Heirloom
by Nswenson0

Comment:
Great idea, great picture, great effectâ€Â¦(7) Why not 10 I hear you say? The gun looks far too modern – I'm no expert on weapons, but it does look really modern – I think anywayâ€Â¦

Vintage FM
by mcmurma

Comment:
Great idea, up against some really inventive stuff in this challenge, but you've caught the theme really well with a technically unfaultable shot (10) Love the hand - makes it look like your seeing back in time...

And This Too My Eyes Have Seen
by sheyingshi88

Comment:
Great picture, love the reflection in dirty, broken glass. Fairly bland, but still good. (8)

old hotel room
by shutterfly

Comment:
Love the lighting, great picture technically... Seems to lose a bit on the composition, but I'm not sure why I feel that... (7)

Antique Kitchen Tool
by Kimbly

Comment:
The photography is not an issue – can't find fault there (6). But – for me – the content is a bit moribund and lacks punchâ€Â¦ That may sound a bit harsh – sorryâ€Â¦ Good luckâ€Â¦

getting old
by mello

Comment:
A bit too subtle - good picture...

Office 1915
by waltoml

Comment:
I think that the composition is a little too sterile. In my opinion, the idea could have been improved greatly with he use of candles and no telephone – I think the phone is overkill. The notion of the solitary novelist writing in the wee small hours would have been a nice ideaâ€Â¦ This is just my opinion – good luckâ€Â¦ (6)

Dinky Cars
by Jean

Comment:
Top - this is just fantastic. Not only is it a great idea, it's a well lit, well composed (or should that be decomposed :) ) picture that jumps out at you. Subject smacks of fun and I smiled when I saw it, meets the challenge without trying - TEN IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH, but it'll have to do -- (10)

The old ladies home
by Azrifel

Comment:
Technically good, but lacking in punch: I would have liked to see more (or less) of the building itself. I think closer in or all the way out to show the whole building would have improved the overall composition – just one opinion(5)

Portrait of an Old Violin
by paganini

Comment:
Great photo. I like the texture in the woodâ€Â¦