Amazing colors of nature
by madmax69

Comment:
What I like:
-Well the title and the picture are always one. The picture alone wouldn't be understandable but with the title it makes sense. Always the whole information comes form the shot and the text.
-I like the colours, although they strike my eyes a bit.

What i don't like
-Well i am guessing there was some post processing. I guess you croped the pic a bit, if you did that why couldn't you eliminate this wood in the left botom hend corner and the sail.

It's a 6 from me.

Good luck :)

Edge of the World
by JCDean

Comment:
What I like:
-Creative
-DOF

Well I understand the idea. You where aming for the amazing part and no for the funny one.
After a short time it does look like a cliff or the edge of the world. Very creative but lacks something pompous. On the other heand i'am not sure if you could make it more pompous. So i give a 7 for the creativity. The shot itself doesn't have the impact matching the title.

Bizarre sky
by Mario66

Comment:
What I like
-Well everything besides the fact that i feel like the shot is leaning to the left. I would rotate it a bit to make the hirozon horizontal

Would give at least a 9 maybe a 10 but i'll keep the score at 7

ShroomHenge
by L1

Comment:
What I like
-love the greens
-love the way you set the mashrooms
-I like pictures that show creativity
-The title fits on a dime

I would chan ge nothing in this pic. Very very creative 10 from me!

Palm
by aphoticshadow

Comment:
What I like:
Everything except those lines and these stick on the right. My my how simple it is to ruin a good pic.

It's not bizzare so the pic itself a 7 but since the chalange is the way it is i give it a 5-6.

Animal communicator
by RSBP

Comment:
What I like
-The atmosphere
-The pose
-both 'animals' ( just a joke ) both subjects have their eyes closed... so magical
What I dislike
-The strong light on there heads.
-The background - hey boy in the red... YES YOU get out of the pic :)

I love it and i try to force myself to see the topic in here. I can't be dishonest so unhappily i give it a 6, but if not for the topic of the challange I would have givin it more credit :)

Birds on the Shoreline
by andywightman

Comment:
What I like:
-damn what an interesting picture
-damn what nice composition
-damn what colours
-damn what perspective
What I dislike:
-Well I dislike me for not beeing able to shoot a pic like that :)

I give it a 10. It is striking in the form and also in the situation it conveys.

alien
by slonko

Comment:
What I like:
-The title
-recently I've seen alien vs predator and well This shot fits :)
-The colours are cold but i feel warm
-The water gives a nice effecr
What I dislike:
-Well don't really know. Maybe i would give a frame, even if it was 1 pixel thick :P

I give you a 9.
Good picture, creative or just lucky, fits the chal;ange. No more to say.

Undressed
by smr78

Comment:
What I like:
-everything that is,

The composition
The lighting
The figure
The gradient ( I love gradients )
The tone of the sky
What I dislike:
-The border is too white :) Maybe too thick - maybe the old conventional black would do better :)
-I am not sure where the amazement is gone, or the laugh :) Bizzare it is not !

So the shot itself is 8 point worth but since the topic is bizzare nature I give it a 6.

PUMPKINS, SQUASH AND GOURDS
by sabphoto

Comment:
What I like:
-Believe it or not, but the composition
-The subject
-The colours
What i dislike:
-The fact that the picture is not PARALLEL to the lense
-As I understand it's neither funny nor amazing or bizzare to me, however the shot and perspective themselves are. So i guess the shot was supposed to be bizzare on it's own.

I give a 6, why? Becuase I am not totaly sure it meet's the chalange.