Leaves
by riley

Comment:
I really like the glow on the background leaf, but it distracts slightly from the smaller version. It would've been nice to have the small leaf slightly sharper or brighter/darker to highlight it a touch more.

Background leaf looks like a surreal landscape with a forked road. I want to dive in and go exploring :).

Gave it an 8, probably deserved a 9 in retrospect.

Addiction
by digistoune

Comment:
I personally like the pink touch, makes the whole thing seem a bit more vintage. Like the inclusion of the "50mm" text in the main subject. Gave it a 10, thought it would go higher than it did!

Little Black Book
by tfaust

Comment:
I thought this would go much higher. Gave it a 10. Loved the background, lighting and b&w finish.

Home Sweet Hole
by scalvert

Comment:
I really loved this one, it creates an interesting illusion. The lighting is lovely and the framing of the subject with the mousehole is perfect.

I might've tried shooting lower on the floor myself, but then I wouldn't have enough imagination to think of something as original as this in the first place!

I gave it an 8, but in retrospect it deserved a 10. I never had enough time to go back and change it. :(

Miniture surf board - or - " Sink Surfing"
by graphicfunk

Comment:
Excellent! I love the colours and background. The action is stopped nicely and it's a great scene overall.

Only thing I'd change myself is that I'd move around the faucet a bit to get some distance between it and the surfer, and reduce DOF to concentrate on getting only the surfer in focus.. but then you might lose the effect of the leading line, not to mention drown your camera :D

Straight 10. Congrats on ribbon.

I've fixed the knocking noise, one of the pistons was too small !!
by KiwiChris

Comment:
I like this one, thought it would go a bit higher. Only thing I have doubts about is the scale, but otherwise, very nice.

Just an ornament
by yael27

Comment:
Very nice antique colours, good focus, but I'm a bit unsure about the composition. Just my personal opinion.

Would've been nicer with a plain black border.

Good image, not related to the challenge though. Gave it a 6, otherwise it might get an 8.

toy boat
by panosm

Comment:
Bit squint, slightly soft, but great colour. Composition is good apart from the fact that it's not level.

Gave it a 6.

It's A Bird Eat Bird World
by birdyblue

Comment:
Excellent idea, reasonable composition, but the lighting is harsh and nasty. Try using natural light next time, or perhaps a lamp/flashlight and a tripod.

Might've been nice to backlight it against a window and create sillouettes?

Composition is alright, although I'd rather it was slightly further away from the birds myself.

Good attempt.

Take A Moment : There are plenty left.
by Curious

Comment:
Simplistic but interesting. Very nice