He Won't Walk Without It
by Adam520

Comment:
I see this is your first entry...keep it up, we look forward to seeing more from you!

I think the focus was the reason that this placed last. You had the right idea and a little more care would have allowed for a much better score. The subject could have also been placed in front of a more dramatic background (perhaps a solid black, white or colour).

The first photo I submitted entered last, but in the 5 or 6 challenges since I have improved my photography skills dramatically and I'm very glad I stuck around to learn from the other members here. I hope to see more of your entries in the future!

Interlude
by Pedro

Comment:
Anything short of a blue ribbon in this challenge means this photo has been underrated...to me, this encapsules the essence of photography.

The discovery of a moment met by the technical skills required to capture it beautifully.

10. Nothing short of it.

Megalomania
by Remie

Comment:
This is the one photo that got away! I definitely had this as a top 5 finisher, but what can you do?

Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful...

Lines, Crossed.
by thatcloudthere

Comment:

Originally posted by luv2photo: I am surprised this did not do better. It truly communicated to me the complexity of electricity.

True, but there are much better ways that I could have photographed this area...it was a rushed shoot and I wasn't into it, otherwise I would have gone back at a better time (not 3 pm) and tried some different shots. I predicted about a 4.8 on this photo, so I can't complain.

Edit: Thank you for the compliment. :)


Message edited by author 2004-10-06 13:05:33.

Split Bout....the inner struggle
by graphicfunk

Comment:
Great idea, neat image...but it doesn't appeal to me a whole lot. I know this must have been difficult to pull off, but the payout isn't there for me personally although I'm sure it will appeal to others...Great work, overall, though!

Edit: I'm scoring this a 6, because it's a neat idea but it just doesn't do a lot for me...

Defeat
by movieman

Comment:
Not nice at all, well done...sad and touching image. I love the overwhelming whites. It was suggested below that darks would have suited the mood but I tend to disagree. The bright white makes it seem like it has been photographed 'from the other side'. Great photo...but again, very sad. I would have given this a 9 or so.

Misty Morning
by jodiecoston

Comment:
Now there we go!!

Captivated
by sher

Comment:
Very, very good! I like this one...Not a helpful comment, just a compliment!
9

Curves n' Lines
by dinn

Comment:
Nice photo. Great use of the number 1.618...

"Back" Cover Girl
by DougPaz

Comment:
A cool idea, and it's actually well done, but there's too much 'other stuff' in the picture to distract me. Perhaps a tighter crop of the face and magazine would have been enough for my tastes?