High and Dry
by orussell

Comment:
There is too much foreground in front of the subject for my taste...but then again, where else would I expect to find the foreground... ;0) If the bottom 40% was cropped off I'd be much happier with that...

The boat looks like it should be a true white, but there's not enough contrast so it seems gray and bland. Neat subject, though!

Tear Drop Blues
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Nice photo...the best part is seeing how much you love this photo in the comment above. It's great when a photo is special to the photographer and is also well received by his/her peers. The best of both worlds!

Congrats!

Forgotten
by agwright

Comment:
I like the idea, title, and composition but that bike just looks too darn new and fresh to have that 'forgotten' look. I know I'm being picky, but only because the right subject would have earned this an 8. As is, I'll score it a 6 because that bike is just too uninteresting. It also seems a little overexposed...

The Artist
by scalvert

Comment:
Great work! What an imaginative depiction of Impressionism! I really hope this wins...

I only wish that the paintbrush and hand were lit/positioned slightly differently, but that won't stop me from handing out the first (and likely only) 9 for this challenge...

Richest Man in Babylon
by frumoaznicul

Comment:
Ohhh...this is the first time I've wanted a print of a dpc photo! To have this hanging on my wall (with the words "beautiful girl" visible on the hat) would be great...

Avalanche
by mrorange002

Comment:
Seems tilted to the left a bit...but I'm kinda crooked-headed so maybe it's just me.

More importantly, this is an incredible photograph!! I would be extremely proud if I had taken this photo...good choice with the black and white!

Birds on the Shoreline
by andywightman

Comment:
Incredible...

Family Affair
by frumoaznicul

Comment:
Underrated. Great photo...gave it an 8.

Closed
by cpanaioti

Comment:
Neat...I photographed this lock itself. It was a dreary day and the reflections didn't look nearly as beautiful as you've captured them. Very nice! It looks neat 'flipped'...like the sky is ripply!

CRW_3773
by Nusbaum

Comment:
I really like this...well done! This photo suffers from the same 'white sky' as many of my October photos which is a bit distracting but in some wise provides some contrast to the nice, warm impression of the blurred leaves.

Great addition to the autumn collection!