The Jetty
by Judi

Comment:
You have some odd colour fringing around the greens under the jetty.

Shadow Surfers
by MichaelC

Comment:
Fascinating concept, and the ghostly skyline in the background adds a good twist to an old cliche. You have a circle of flare in the upper middle that I'd have cleaned up. One of my highest scores in this contest.

Light and Shadow
by crik

Comment:
This subject would have worked better without such a strong colour cast, and I'm not a fan of the asymmetrical border (white stripe thicker on the right and below).

Upstream
by Kroburg

Comment:
Very strong work, flawless tones and clarity, well composed, not oversharpened... excellent! The only tiny flaw is you missed cloning out a dust spot; it being located on the intersection of the lower left third makes it especially prominent. One of my highest scores in this contest.

Message edited by author 2016-12-02 08:10:22.

Ground Fog, Moon and Stars
by grahamgator

Comment:
Interesting subject, and the brave composition - central and framed below middle - works very well here. One nit to pick is that I can see distinct steps in gradation in the the tones in the sky, from excess contrast / saturation changes there - I would have smoothed this out in postprocessing. There's also what looks like a bit of flare in the lower left above the trees that could be cleaned up. Still, one of my highest scores in this challenge.

Across the Moonlit Bay
by PenelopeK

Comment:
There's a thin patch of shadow beneath the lights of the hut which is darker than the rest of the surrounding hillside, and looks very artificial - fixing that would improve this somewhat.

Hvitserkur
by HalldorIngi

Comment:
Having the horizon level would have improved this.

Yacht-Ship-Super Moon
by mqnaufal

Comment:
Good composition, but there are some strange pixellation artefacts around the top and bottom of your moon.

moon
by jmritz

Comment:
Interesting composition and concept.

Supermoon
by Bensted

Comment:
Good concept and composition, but just a bit too much grain for it to work - and strange noise reduction artefacts along the building, as well as an odd blue line to the right of it.