America's Homeless Rate Climbs to New Highs
by JBosie

Comment:
Looks like a ribbon winner to me. 10

Charity Horse Show Names Grand Champion
by rmlutgen

Comment:
Your composition ,subject ,angle of shot title are all very good and meet the challenge perfectly. What is wrong ,well it is a little overexposed(look at the sky),the hand on the horse should not be there. For these reasons I scored it down and gave you a 6.

Walked away, heard them say "Poison hearts will never change"
by artvet

Comment:
Great photo lousy headline it speaks volumes socially yet the headline you chose is not a headline but a commentary. Scored you a 7 where a well written"headline "would have scored you an 8 for sure.

Your choice of title while a poignaint social commentary leaves me wondering why you chose it for this challenge?

Good Luck in the challenge

Local flooding infuriates wet commuters
by Cam

Comment:
I see a picture similar to this every year in my local paper.
Well done 7

Immigrants' rights: A forgotten agenda
by ramevi

Comment:
I would have liked to se what colors popped out on this one it meets the challenge very well in both subject and title. 7

In the place between what you know, and what you fear, they struggle !
by Utopian

Comment:
Great picture lousy headline. Not in its meaning, but that saying would never be a headline in a newspaper.
I hate to score down for title however this challenge almost demands that we do.
I gave you a 7 whereas a good headline would have scored this an 8 or higher.
That said,this is an fantastic picture of human emotion and struggle.

Good Luck in the challenge

Why is this alien on top of the Space Needle? Story on page B3
by caba

Comment:
Supermarket tabloid headline. Brilliant 7

A Nation Reflects, Mourns
by slim

Comment:
Very journalistic good choice of topic color conversion and headline. A 9 in my books.

Refinery Disaster
by sahko

Comment:
An amazing photo I gave it a 9. Wish I took this shot

POLICE UNVEIL ATVS FOR BEACH PATROL
by ellamay

Comment:
In my top 5 It is very reminicient of a Newspaper shot. Headline is good , the grain... I dunno if you added but most modern day news photos are not grainy.
I gave it a 9