Crushed...
by SJCarter

Comment:
I like the lighting-very well done.
And the texture of the arm and hand are greay also.
I don't really like the heart it looks too 2 dimensional and it would have been nice to have seen more of the "dust(?)" flowing down.
but a good photo anyway.

Blown Away
by Cooz

Comment:
I can just make out the heart on the right.
and the colors are good.
probably not a "strong" enough image of a heart for my liking though.
maybe I'm just too fussy-there's no pleasing some people :-)

Our Hearts Are With You
by jfwolpert

Comment:
this is another one of those images that without the title it wouldn't fit the challenge.
not that I'm going to vote you down for that.
I just felt like typing something.

Love In A Bottle
by KuriKuri

Comment:
if you had bought another bar of chocolate, you could have filled in more of the gaps in the heart and made more of an impact.
that's what I think anyway!!!!!

Stone
by e301

Comment:
great colors, and leading lines and use of the rule of thirds.
you've done this before, haven't you?
my only suggestion would be to try and get some kind of more prominent reflection in the water-like the sky or clouds?

Key to Her Heart
by verg

Comment:
maybe if the other necklace had been taken off, then the key would have stood out more?
good attempt though.
and good luck.

L'Amour
by Tallbloke

Comment:
i thought this was robbie williams from the thumb nail!!!!!

i really like the black and white and the emotion shown.
the subject matter is maybe not quite right (although it is perfect for the challenge)
but if it had said "dad" on his arm and he was looking at an old photograph of his "dad", then it would have hit a sentimental vote too.
that's what I think anyway.

A Restless Sleep
by Coley

Comment:
yes, I like this too.
very well done.
I can't be bothered to read through the other posts, so sorry if this comment is repetitive:
I think what stops this shot from being a really great shot instead of just a great shot (an 8 instead of a 9 or a 10 if you will) is the light on the horizon.
If you could have had the sky/background black, then it would have turned it up that extra notch needed to put it amongst the greats!!!!
well done anyway.

Simply LOVE
by NstiG8tr

Comment:
it almost seems to move when you look at it.
it also looks like a greetings card.
not very constructive Criticism i know, but still.........

Chocolate cake
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
this just looks like you've taken a picture of a heart shaped cake with the words "I love you" on it.
If that's the case, then it's not really very creative.
perhaps if it was put in an "exciting" enviroment or was being "broken" or or or or......you get my point!
Nicw colors and focusing though.