Rusty Fence
by Ambo

Comment:
Nice colors. I would have cropped the trees onteh left and right out, they draw the eye away from the fence. I'd also like to see the fence in focus. Try again with a tripod and your aperture set to f8 and see what a difference it makes.

Guggenheim Museum
by lpnyc

Comment:
Rusted? Where? The photo is pretty small, so if there is rust it's been made invisible. You should enter photos at a larger size (as large as possible) so that we can see the whole thing clearly.

...ring n ring n ring...
by euclids

Comment:
There is nothing rusted. The focus is on the upper left rings of the notebook. Is that what you want us to look at? Why?

Rusty Rainbow
by larrylef

Comment:
At least some portion of your photo should be in focus. I love the colors, but there is not enough of the subject showing to see what it is. I think it's a tire on a rusty wheel well, with a pine needle stuck to it? Could have been good with better focus and a little more of the subject showing.

Rusted Ruy Lopez
by frychikn

Comment:
Poor focus, distracting background and an unclear subject are reasons I'm voting this low. In the future you should try to make some of the lines in the photo parallel to the frame of your photo and avoid the hot spot in the lower portion when using flash by not pointing the camera directly at the reflective surface. Throsing a tablecloth over the stained glass surface will emilinate the distracting background and using a higher f stop (aperture at f8) will allow more of the photo to be in focus.

That wasn't too bad, a little "rusty" though
by Beastman

Comment:
Technically, this photo is fine. Personally I don't like the subject or the interptretation of the challenge. Two orange objects have nothing to do with 'rusted', and 'rusty' was also not the topic.

@_@
by unikorn

Comment:
Focus: 5
Post-processing: 5
Does it fit the challenge? 3
Composition (Background, Cropping, Framing): 3
Technical (Exposure, lighting): 2
Does it capture my interest? 1

Overall Rating: 2

Fighter jet
by Samspon

Comment:
Focus: 3
Post-processing: 3
Does it fit the challenge? 1
Composition (Background, Cropping, Framing): 2
Technical (Exposure, lighting): 2
Does it capture my interest? 1

Overall Rating: 2

Rusted Ironbox
by Allan

Comment:
Focus is terrible and there's no rust that I can see anwhere in the photo. Your horizon is tilted and you have water or flare on the top part of your picture. 1

Shadows of the Old West
by autool

Comment:
Love the idea, but I find it distracting that the barrel and grip are cut off.