Hush little baby don't say a word
by d95vette

Comment:
nice dogs, nice dog picture... i have taken tons of dog pictures myself - of my own dogs and their dog-friends... i love them all! the question to ask yourself here: does it work as an entry to a photography challenge? i mean, any photography challenge, not just for silence... i honestly don't think so... i wouldn't even know how to score it, so i will just leave this comment...

If It Clashes - Wear It!
by basia03

Comment:
thanks a lot for all your helpful comments.

sparrow640
by robdoc

Comment:
conflicted sparrow?

Tomorrow: Generally sunny. Very cold. High 18F. Winds NW at 10 to 20 mph.
by basia03

Comment:
thank you very much for all your positive and helpful comments... the crop and dof were intentional, of course, but it was interesting to hear whether people liked the effect of it or not...

polar plunge
by Seanachai

Comment:
i loved this picture and gave it a six, sorry didn't have a chance to comment during the challenge... breathtaking... pun intended...

Time for work
by Claya

Comment:
i like this picture a lot, sorry i didn't vote in this challenge... one of the most creative interpretations...

Let Go Of Reality For An Evening, Immerse Yourself In A Great Novel
by TommyMoe21

Comment:
i loved this picture, sorry didn't have a chance to comment during the challenge... i would've cropped just below the nose though...

joie de vivre (zhwä d vvr) Hearty or carefree enjoyment of life.
by basia03

Comment:
thank you for your helpful comments... and by that i mean comments i marked as "helpful", of course...all except one...

Soaring
by photoqwest

Comment:
i am sorry, this is much too small, you are allowed to use up to 640 on the longer side and regulate the size by the jpeg compression... as it is, this picture doesn't make am impact it could...

Free your mind.
by dinn

Comment:
this is one "wow" picture... don't have any suggestions for improvement, this silhouette looks absolutely perfect to me...