Carmel Sunset
by Venom

Comment:
Fine, but nothing special (and the horizon is a bit leaning too). You made the good choice, your entry was great!

Robin
by bobonacus

Comment:
Very unusual POV (for a bird's capture), your entry was more creative, but this is also original and, with a bit cropping on left side and below, leaving the bird less centered, this could have done better in the FS challenge IMO

Coal: All of ya!
by heavyj

Comment:
Funny, good idea, good technique too

Holiday Reflections
by essay

Comment:
very well done, a welcome fresh sight on the old theme of reflection

Twilight Hour
by Brent_S

Comment:
Impressive work, the clarity is awesome

Stapi
by skari

Comment:
Very beautiful and powerful B&W, but the sharpening is above the limit and the white dots are distracting

Winter's Shadowed Footprints
by J-Me

Comment:
Would be much better...without the footprints IMO!
Seems also over-saturated
The shadows are nice indeed

Jubelpark
by inshaala

Comment:
Nice, HDR a bit above the limit though

Style
by JaimeVinas

Comment:
Great portrait, good cropping, good light, background blurred and neutral enough, but not insipid, just the right lower angle slightly distracting

Run over - human vs. animal!
by thomasjessen

Comment:
Well...
You'll probably get a ton of 1 and some shocked comments, but for me, this is an excellent photography:
- There's a (clear) message about the preservation of wildlife
- The way you express the message is strong enough, immediately understandable
- The image is harsh, but still only documentary, reflecting nothing else than a reality
- And finally, it's an excellent photographic work, where a few elements, a good composition and a good use of DOF are perfectly combining to tell us something.
I wouldn't hang it on my wall and it's not in my fav, but I rate it high for its qualities - with a bonus point for the courage to post it amongst purple sunsets an snowy woods.