Hull
by Mr_Pants

Comment:
I'm not fond of this photo for his challenge because I think there is more frame then subject. Not only that but I had to re-read your title to fully understand what the photo was about. I think this photo would have done better in the rusted challenge. Good luck in this challenge. <4>

The Doorway
by Coley

Comment:
I've looked at this photo several times now and have yet to see the frame. It's a nice portrait with excellent clarity, contrast and the lack of color really makes this photo unique but in my opinion it does not meet the challenge. <5>

Rust
by eyesightphoto

Comment:
I wish the pressure gauge was clean to make it stand out more in the photo. I like the framing and clarity of this photo and find the photo to have an overall pleasing feel to it. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <7>

Hot Wheel
by DefyTime

Comment:
I'm not fond of this photo but I can't quite figure out why. prehaps its the lack of color??? or the shadow under the truck??? not sure. However it does fit the challenge but IMO the frame/background/foreground is bigger then the subject. Good luck in this challenge. <5>

Within the shade
by ergo

Comment:
I've been looking at this photot then left then came back and yet I still don't see a frame. Overall I think the photo is a nice photo and a very pleasing one to look at but I don't see the connection to this challenge. Good luck. <4>

Dugon Falls
by ace flyman

Comment:
Seeing the frame is not as easy as some photo's IMO this photo does meet the challenge. It is very pleasing to the eye and has great colors, clarity and crispness. I find it to be a little on the dark side tho but find the dark brings out the greens which is nice for a change. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <8>

ta-daaa
by 4score

Comment:
I'm not fussy of you subject. I find it lacking and uninspirational. I also don't like the roof showing thru on the top left side and find it to be distracting. Good luck in this challenge. <7>

Little Bird
by bobdaveant

Comment:
I like the DoF but find it gives a OoF to the rest of the photo (just slightly). Perhaps its just a contrast issue. Good luck in this challenge. <5>

Arizona Sunset: Rays of Light Framed by Saguaro
by lwphotography

Comment:
I guess it meets the challenge. Barely IMO but it does. However I find the frame and subject are not perportionate and there is more background the subject. I like the sun setting and the crispness/clarity of the silohouette but the unpreportionate sizes is to much. Good luck in this challenge. <6>

Framed in Rock
by Steveinnz

Comment:
way to bright and way to much contrast. The contrast is washing the colors away and the brightness is taking away from the detail. Good luck in this challenge. <4>