untitled
by darylbrown

Comment:
I'd rather see this without the flashlight. I think the composition could be more appealing if the lantern weren't knocked over. Good background, nice coloring.

Grumpy Old Men
by tyd

Comment:
Meets the challenge! The overall tonality has too much blue.

Not going Anywhere!
by Point

Comment:
Black and white works well here and it clearly fits the challenge. I'd like to see a slightly different angle to include more of the front of the engine, but that's just me.

Gothic Detail
by kmtolk

Comment:
It's great that you got low enough to capture this good angle. There is a little too much detail crowded into this composition though. For the most part the dof is good. So is the light exposure. Although I love blue skies, in this case a black and white image would have sufficed. The blue draws my attention away from the detail of the subject.

The Old Don Cesar
by Photo Jim

Comment:
This is nice but seems to be tilting down to the left. I would like to have seen a little more color saturation in the picture to give it more punch. The palms for example could be greener. The sky would add drama if it was a little more contrasted. Seems to meet the "old" challenge.

Time Passages
by Gotcha

Comment:
I like the textural background, and love the repetitious circles represented by the watch and wheels. I must admit that it bothers me to have part of the horse's head showing and not the whoe thing and would like the watch to be over to my left more, to overlap the wheel. I'm sure many would disagree so it really is just a matter of taste. All that said, I do like this image.

Atom 153
by boyte1

Comment:
Aside from the little particles, hair, etc, on the blue surface I like this. It was the same flaws in my own picture that kept me from submitting one of my favorites. Still giving you a high score though.

Yester Years
by spiller

Comment:
Nice color saturation, good focus, meets challenge, good dof. Congrats!

Old Brick
by estamper

Comment:
On my monitor I can't see the brick because the image is too dark. I'd also like to see it off-center. Sure does meet the "something old" challenge though.

Centenarian
by autool

Comment:
I can see the age in the patina of the wood. My submission is somewhat similar and many people just don't see the age in it, because it has been well preserved for many, many years. I thought they'd see that but didn't. I hope your's is scoring better than mine....:-) I like yours.