Interrogation
by MAK

Comment:
Good portrait, but just don't get the Noir feel from this. -1 for unlit cigarette. Lighting is ok but I find the white had and white tie too distracting and rather conflicting with the noir genre (if that makes sense). Still solid effort. 6

She's all but gone...
by sjhuls

Comment:
Great shot! One of my favorites!

Guaranteed Win
by Jon_H

Comment:
Good lighting, great action sequence, portrays a Noir feel. Should do very well!

Another Dark Tale From The Naked City...
by mefnj

Comment:
This is one of the better shots in the challenge. Great composition, lighting and props (attention to detail). Had a similar idea glad I did not do it because you executed superbly! Well done!

Paper Hero - Here to save the dame, little did he know the man was proposing to his woman.
by davidfallsmith

Comment:
Very creative. One of my favorites int he challenge this should do well!

The Stalker
by jagar

Comment:
Well composed, great lighting tells a story in a real Noir setting. Possibly in the top 5 on my list and one of my higher votes.

The Story Of Malcolm,,,
by mrbig65

Comment:
I am giving this image a 2 because I can't see anything besides some lighter areas on the middle / lower right of the frame.

King Kong
by Levoy

Comment:
I gave this a 2 for several reasons and here is why: 1. The image is poorly composed (the leaves in the lower left corner are distracting as is the light wooden pole behind the gorilla and the top black portion). 2. The subject is not sharp / in focus. Besides the subject being severely underexposed there is nothing which suggests Noir lighting style. No shadow/light play, etc. 3 Finally, King Kong was not a Noir film and thus I believe this image DNMC. In summary, I gave this a low vote because I don't think this image took a lot of thought / effort nor conveyed the mood of the challenge topic.

Distraction
by josephtagle

Comment:
Very nice!

Murder on Montrose Way
by LevT

Comment:
My only 10 so far! Fantastic job!!!