Marina at sunset
by aznym

Comment:
If you crop the bottom three waves off, about one third from the bottom off and make a panorama like that, then you'll have a much better photo. No matter though the horizon line will be in the middle. Like that I would have rated it 1-2 higher, the upper part is good. There is too much of uninteresting foreground like it is.

Did someone say study?
by jadkpics

Comment:
Good editing.

Defiant
by seriocomic

Comment:
Nice use of bokeh, maybe a little bit too yellow, but good in whole.

Lace
by joynim

Comment:
Good cat photo, the cat is well positioned inside the frame.

John
by ClickNSee

Comment:
Lennon? hehe, this is an average portrait. The eyes should be in sharp focus.

Heartland
by NstiG8tr

Comment:
You should have been closer to one of the rolls to have it in the foreground, the foreground lacks interest and the horizon line is positioned too near the center, a lower or maybe higher aim would be better.

Autumn Light
by shabbychic

Comment:
Good, but would be better with all of the flowers to the right inside the frame. Good use of light.

thinking
by arsenal

Comment:
Great photo, I like it. It's creative with unique editing. Try crop a little bit off from the left, maybe all the way to the "lock"(?) on the door or maybe just have all of the person's right foot inside the frame with a little bit space from it to the edge. I think the darkest area to the left isn't necessary. Good job, I like it when people get creative and it works out this good. Great job!

Boundless
by 4score

Comment:
A vertical crop with a little bit more foreground would be better I think.

When is Daddy coming home?
by mandyturner

Comment:
Nice, I like the brush strokes, although I think they aren't necessary. One of the better photos in this challenge.