P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by streetpigeon:
Here I distinctly prefer the b & w image. The indistinctness favors the latter approach, there being greater latitude as a creative decision. The contrasts work more nicely here and the graininess of the dog plays well with the graininess of the screen, as if the image is being sent back to earth from deep space. Nice.

P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by streetpigeon:
The color image has a freshness of a new day feel that is quite appealing, the bright grass and effulgent horizon. The dog is, as some have said, more picked out in this version. However, I like the b & w version just as much, distantly related as it superficially appears. I like that you must look deeper, for that's exactly how to spot animals in the wild. The trees are more prominent and function as witnesses, even distractions. I admire your efforts.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by mariuca:
I like the feel in both pics. The one in color is very touching should you crop and leave the doggie only. I know you try minimal but even in B&W Katee needs the stage without the tv in the background

P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by digifotojo:
I agree with the harsh feeling on the b/w image..grass looks almost prickly. The color version adds an overall warmer feeling. It all depends on the kind of impression you're attempting to achieve. The b/w version is definitely more artistic. I think comparing the two tends to alter one's visual experience. The b/w version is a better image overall.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by digifotojo:
The B/W image works better here, not a fan of the OOF look but that's just me.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by insteps:
Agree with jagar again... he seems to know what he's talking about. My only advice would be to use Viveza to bring out some detail in her face.

P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by insteps:
ART5 is a little harsh for this subject. Less contrast with more gray tones would work better. I'd probably keep it as color unless b&w was required.

agendas
by roz

Comment by insteps:
Roz, this is terrific! Some anticipation and tension along with beautiful geometry. A lethal combination. I agree with jagar about the border. This image doesn't need faux finishes or gimmicks. KISS (Keep It Simple Stupid) works best sometimes.

P3023592 - SOOC comparison 1100pxls
by roz

Comment by MargaretNet:
Not sure about this as everything is blurred so it is difficult to see the subject (?)

P3023714 - SOOC comparison 1000pxls
by roz

Comment by MargaretNet:
Agree with jagar's comment, the in-camera B&W treatment does not work in this case. I also personally object to calling processing in camera "minimal" ;)